Striker fired ranking opinions wanted
Being a well known gLoCk hater, pick one of the others that fit your hands and you shoot well.
All of their controls are slightly different and there is no shortage of pistols that are better than gLoCk from a number of aspects.
ETA: I own two of the models you listed, my personal experience is that the VP9 is better than the M&P, in my hands. I still own the M&P and it too would be a solid choice.
I see others are recommending the PPQ which is a fine pistol as well but it wasn't on your list. I own a V1 PPQ and would rank it behind the VP9 and slightly ahead of the M&P. The PPQ has better ergonomics than the M&P but not as good as the VP9. The magazine release on the V1 is too thin. I'm spoiled by the HK style magazine release, so the V2 doesn't appeal much to me, already owning the V1.