Originally Posted by
warpedcamshaft
This is a tough one. I would like to hear other peoples input on the subject. This is a classic argument.
For small weapons (jframe size revolvers and Kahr/Keltec size auto in 380 or 9mm):
Revolvers offer some distinct advantages:
Contact shots.
Will not fail to load a new round during physical altercations or limp wristing. (con: Grabbing the weapon around the cylinder will prevent trigger from being pulled)
Feed all types of ammunition.
Ammunition does not get seriously damaged from loading/unloading.
Leaving gun loaded for years will not cause magazine issues.
Very reliable
Autos:
Generally more rounds available.
Slimmer/flatter profile.
Faster reloads.
Lighter DA triggers or SA triggers (pending on design)