Quote Originally Posted by okie john View Post
Several knowledgable trainers (LAV, Kyle DeFoor, Mac among them) have noted that students armed with a Gen1/2/3 G17 seem to shoot 10-15% better than those armed with a Gen1/2/3 G19.

Has anyone seen this same discrepancy between Gen4 G17 and G19 pistols?

Thanks,


Okie John
What is "better?" More accurate? More quickly? Concealed better? Looked better in tactical pictures?
What is the context of the question? If you're deciding between the two, I don't think it will matter. Pick whichever you like more, and shoot the hell out of it. I seriously doubt you'll shoot it better or worse than the other, in appreciable differences.

I don't get why you, or anybody, cares what the trainers think on something so insignificant. Pick one. Shoot one. You'll be just fine.