Sig P228R vs Glock 19

[AR15thur]

I know there are like 9000 "help me pick a 9mm" threads, but I'm still at a loss.

I've handled examples of both, shot both, and here are the facts:
The Sig feels great and I'm more accurate with it
The Glock felt fine too, and I own a Glock 17, though I'm not completely sold on it yet.

I know that Sig has some QC problems of late, but the 228R is a German/American hybrid, so I don't know if they are a little less susceptible to problems.

I've also read of some cheap out-sourced parts on the Glock 19, and that they're susceptible to 'limp-wristing'. I've also read that some larger bullets may have a hard time being chambered in the 19.

I need something reliable and small enough for carry, and I want something that I can maintain relatively easily as well.

Does anyone have an opinion between the two? Or can someone recommend something better?

[IrishDevil]

"I need something reliable and small enough for carry, and I want something that I can maintain relatively easily as well."

You just described the 19, but the 228 is a great handgun also. I think the Glock would better suit your needs as they have been described.

[Vinh]

I wouldn't look at it in terms of build quality.

More along the lines of this:
If you have unlimited time and money for training and ammo, I might consider the Sig.
If not, then don't.

The Glock will require much less effort when it comes to shooting and maintenance.

[SteyrAUG]

Take a look at the SIG Pro before you decide.

[GLOCKMASTER]

I have carried a P228 and a G19 and I feel that you cannot go wrong with either one. I have been carring a G19 for several years now also I own a spare G19 and I have never had an issue with either one. I just prefer the G19 over the 228.

I say that you cannot go wrong with either one. Don't get hung up on the small stuff if you are trying to decide between these two companies and pistols.

[AR15thur]

Also, can anyone comment on the durability of the 228 slide vs. the 229 version?

My defense ammunition is Federal 147gr HST. I don't really put any +p rounds through any of my guns.