Actually, that seems fairly accurate.
It's been a while, but I spent several years reading just about everything I could get my hands on relating to the military aspect of the CW. Memoirs, histories . . . the US Ordinance Manual of 1861 (read every page except for the logarithm tables ).
Also, I've read Alvin York's memoirs, and various other "black powder" type accounts. Basically, York said that for anything under 100 yards (such as shooting turkeys in the head at local matches), he preferred a "hog rifle" to any of the modern arms.
From everything I have read, a ten inch group at 200 yards is very doable.
My rapier lay across my knees, and I ran my hand down its worn scabbard. "Here's one that agrees with me," I said. "And up there is Another," and I lifted my hat in acknowledgment of the One True Lawgiver, to whom every man's laws must bow, even those of a King.
He stared. "God and my good sword!" he cried. "A very knightly dependence . . ."
Bookmarks