NEW Comparison Chart of Commercial M4 Pattern Carbines

[ucrt]

SWAT article was Abner Miranda. Mine was in Guns & Weapons for LE.

======================================

Heck, I remember you mentioning your article about Spike's, thought it was SWAT...Oh well...

Do you know the two signs of getting old?
One is you start to lose your memory...and I can't remember what the second one is...

.

[C4IGrant]

Looks good!



C4

[gs013564]

SWAT article was Abner Miranda. Mine was in Guns & Weapons for LE.

I still have that magazine and, for a second there, I was confused!

Again, thanks for your efforts in pulling this together.

[mtdawg169]

Rob, can you shed any light on the "other" responses from DD?

[ST911]

I have updated the new Chart to include a link right in the document that takes you to the legacy E of F, as well as the link at the bottom of the Chart to the discussion that has been updated to link to this thread.

I have also added a box at the top of the Chart explaining the method by which it was populated so as to remove any of the "one man's biased opinion" sniping that I've had to listen to since I started the first Chart.

Nicely done. Form, content, and self-reporting by the manufacturers avoids criticism on the subjective nature of certain line items. Example: staking is listed, but adequacy thereof is to be verified.

Olympic Arms's input makes it a stand out. Simultaneously savvy and evasive.

[Boss Hogg]

Nothing from KAC?

[rob_s]

Nothing from KAC?

Do they make an M4?

[tnt1106]

(removed while I attempt to educate myself further.)


added: Thank you Rob for the updated chart and all that went into composing it.

[rob_s]

KAC SR-15 http://www.knightarmco.com/sr15.html ?

no.

..

[badness]

what does the "1" stand for under spikes tactical's MPI barrel testing? Does that mean they only test 1 per batch? Or was that ment to be 100% but a mistake was made?

I ask because under HPT Bolt testing for SIONICS, you put Samples, so if spikes only takes batch or sample testing for their MPI barrel tests, i assumed it would say the same. (Samples).