I've found a flashlight that really impressed me recently.
I found it at Lowe's building supply of all places.
It's a "Task Force" item #225285. It has a 3 watt LED that puts out a WHOPPING 150 Lumens. It has the push button tail switch and throws a really tight and bright beam. The best part is it uses two "C" cell batteries. No expensive CR 123A batteries. Just off the shelf "C" cells. I have several flashlights that use the CR123A batteries and with a one hour battery life, on average, those are expensive lights to run.
One of the draws of LED lights, aside from the LOOONG bulb life is, LED flashlight beams have no shadows in the beam. It's a solid pool of light.
It has waaay better throw than other LED lights I've seen and tried.
For example, I have a 5 watt LED "Lenser" flashlight (from Coast Cutlery) that uses 5 "C" cells and it doesn't have the downrange throw this Task Force light has. Sure, it's bright as the dickens, just doesn't throw that beam downrange all that well.
Best part saved for last, the sticker price is $24.95.
edited to add:
I'm a flashlight junky. Now, I have to go check out those two lights you're talking about. Just can't help myself. I'm a flashlight fool.