PDA

View Full Version : My Tavor Review



CoryCop25
06-30-13, 14:41
Disclosure: I am writing this with permission and by the request of Ken Hackathorn.

I spent the day at Mr. Hackathorn's ranch yesterday. During conversation, we began speaking about the Tavor. Of corse Ken gets up, walks away and comes back with his Tavor. His Tavor was equipped with an Aimpoint Micro H-1, a Surefire M600 scout light, a padded VCAS sling and a Daniel Defense forward grip. Ken handed me the rifle and quickly showed me how to operate it. The controls were in OKAY locations and the safety reminded me of a 90 degree SCAR safety. The trigger was heavy but crisp. Ken told me that he had removed one of the trigger springs and it brought the pull from 12# to about 8#.

We ran drills on his range for about 4 hours. There were a few of his friends from the area and another friend of his from back East. We did mostly pistol work but during some of the carbine drills, Ken used the Tavor. Ken was using about 4 magazines. One was the magazine that came with the rifle (Pmag copy), an old Lancer L5 and two GI metal mags. I would guess that during the 5 or 6 carbine drills we did, the Tavor had some kind of stoppage 3 times. I know that he grounded the two GI mags after they didn't work in one of the carbines his friend was using but I did not keep track of what mags he was using during the stoppages. All of the stoppages with any AR yesterday were magazine realted.

After we ended the day and cleaned the range up a bit, I loaded 25 rounds in the supplied Israli mag and 20 rounds in the lancer L5 mag. I started off with the Lancer mag and shot a 20 round group at 25 yards. My goal was combat accuracy at a decent speed to determine if I could feel the bolt lock back on empty. The Tavor did not malfunction at all during these 20 rounds and I did feel the bolt lock to the rear. I then attempted a reload as fast as I could. I would describe the reload as awkward. I reached up to release the empty mag and then I suddenly realized that I was now holding an empty mag. I dropped it and reached for the spare. I loaded it in, pulled on it to make sure that it was secure in the mag well and reached my thumb to the rear and released the bolt. I immediately realizd that I looked at the rifle and not the target the entire reload process.

After the reload, I attempted to shoot at Ken's long range steel torso that was 160 yards away with about a 30 degree incline. This is where the trigger becomes a crutch. I could not hit the target standing unsupported. I was shooting my AR with a 4 MOA H-1 at that target unsupported, several times. I then moved to a fence post and still did not hit the steel. I then went to a knee and supported the Tavor on the fence and pressed off a clean shot and hit it dead center.

With the remaining 19 rounds, I went back t the 25 yard line and walked it in while moving left, right and diagnal until I was about 5 yards away and shooting faster as I got closer. This is where I was beginning to notice the recoil impulse. As I would shoot, the rifle would recoil to the rear and the Aimpoint would strike my hat brim. This was not muzzle flip. As the Tavor's bolt would cycle, it could be felt in my shoulder and it feels like a lot more mass than the bolt cycling in an AR.

As I finished up and handed Mr. Hackathorn his rifle back, we were talking about our observations with the Tavor. As we were talking, Ken was touching the barrel to feel how hot it was and he noticed that the A2 style flash hider was loose and pointing to the right. He told me that this could have been a factor in me not being able to hit the long range target. The flash hider is not supported by a crush washer, it has a jamb nut instead. We don't know how long this had been loose.

Mr. Hackathorn explained his summation of the Tavor perfectly. He said that like any new gun, you become enamored with it but now hos love for the Tavor is wearing off. The Tavor, in his opinion is the best of the bullpups. You can switch shoulders with it and it won't spit brass in your face like the AUG. The Tavor also has the same shortcomings as all of the bullpup designs, like the poor trigger and heavy recoil impuse. If the Tavor becomes more popular, Mr. Geissele needs to get to work fast!

I personnaly was not impressed and other than it looking pretty neat, I will keep my ARs. While I was shooting, Ken took some pictures and videos. In the video, you can see the recoil impulse that I am talking about.

Here is a pretty cool shot of the spent case being ejected....
http://i1014.photobucket.com/albums/af269/CoryCop25/In%20Action/null_zps688785fc.png (http://s1014.photobucket.com/user/CoryCop25/media/In%20Action/null_zps688785fc.png.html)

Click the picture for the video.....
http://i1014.photobucket.com/albums/af269/CoryCop25/Videos/th_24618B2F-30AA-4396-A970-6249AFD772C9-469-000000243971B267_zps626551f6.jpg (http://i1014.photobucket.com/albums/af269/CoryCop25/Videos/24618B2F-30AA-4396-A970-6249AFD772C9-469-000000243971B267_zps626551f6.mp4)

High Tower
06-30-13, 18:53
Nice review. I am more than a little jealous of you spending a day with the great Ken Hackathorn.

Littlelebowski
06-30-13, 18:57
Am I crazy or did you move recently?

Good review, might save me some money.

kest_01
06-30-13, 19:05
Nice review, thanks. Not enough to make think about picking one of these up on favor of an AR though.

calvin118
06-30-13, 19:25
Your experience closely mirrors my own. The trigger and shot recovery issues outweigh the benefit of shorter OAL.

CoryCop25
06-30-13, 19:33
Am I crazy or did you move recently?

Good review, might save me some money.

Our family has a summer home out here. Benn coming out here for 30 years now. Actually this is my 30th year...


Nice review, thanks. Not enough to make think about picking one of these up on favor of an AR though.

Don't get me wrong, I am not trying to discourage the sale of these...


Your experience closely mirrors my own. The trigger and shot recovery issues outweigh the benefit of shorter OAL.

I would like to see what thhis could do in a CQB environment in controlled bursts on full auto. Too slow on followup shots on semi due to recoil and trigger reset.

SeriousStudent
06-30-13, 20:54
CoryCop25, thank you very much for posting your observations. I was curious about this weapon, but have never even seen one in the flesh.

And please pass on all of our good wishes and thanks to Mr. Hackathorn.

CoryCop25
06-30-13, 21:30
CoryCop25, thank you very much for posting your observations. I was curious about this weapon, but have never even seen one in the flesh.

And please pass on all of our good wishes and thanks to Mr. Hackathorn.

Thank You and I will. He is a great man and a good friend.

Vulture38
06-30-13, 21:49
Thank you for posting this review Sir.

Belloc
06-30-13, 23:37
It seems a lot of people are rather unhappy with the trigger: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dizuRNL0HIs&feature=c4-overview&list=UUZ-qxagOkAmCEP-Tu6YliUQ

MountainRaven
07-01-13, 11:56
Geissele needs to make something for this....

Thanks for the review! It's nice to know that even the best can become enamored with new shiny things.

Vash1023
07-01-13, 13:00
thank you for the great read

ShipWreck
07-01-13, 13:23
Very good review. Thanks!

Ick
07-01-13, 13:29
Excellent review.


I would describe the reload as awkward. I reached up to release the empty mag and then I suddenly realized that I was now holding an empty mag. I dropped it and reached for the spare. I loaded it in, pulled on it to make sure that it was secure in the mag well and reached my thumb to the rear and released the bolt. I immediately realizd that I looked at the rifle and not the target the entire reload process.


Translation: Unfamiliar rifle is... unfamiliar.

CoryCop25
07-01-13, 14:29
Excellent review.



Translation: Unfamiliar rifle is... unfamiliar.

You are absolutely correct. However, no matter what you do you will always have an empty magazine in your hand during a reload. That is not going to go well with what most of us are used to.

MountainRaven
07-01-13, 15:01
You are absolutely correct. However, no matter what you do you will always have an empty magazine in your hand during a reload. That is not going to go well with what most of us are used to.

Seen this? (http://youtu.be/VJPgEozoHUA)

And where it actually starts to get relevant.... (http://youtu.be/VJPgEozoHUA?t=7m45s)

Ick
07-01-13, 15:36
Excellent illustration of sub-1 second reload.

bm176
07-01-13, 16:38
no empty mag in hand while reloading here
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5_ULLl-8jk0&feature=player_detailpage
one day I will be this fast with my tavor:)

Littlelebowski
07-01-13, 16:46
no empty mag in hand while reloading here
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5_ULLl-8jk0&feature=player_detailpage
one day I will be this fast with my tavor:)

I'm still figuring out what happened there :D

darr3239
07-01-13, 17:08
Guys with a little more experience on the platform have learned to bump the mag release with their hand, pretty much at the base of the thumb.

Failure2Stop
07-01-13, 17:45
That reload requires a lot of things to go right.

Finally got my hands on one, and while it is still the only non-NFA bullpup I would actually pay for, there are still a lot of the continuing bullpup issues.

If you like/want/need a bullpup, this is the way to go at present.

Typos brought to you via Tapatalk and autocorrect.

CoryCop25
07-01-13, 18:55
Jack is exactly correct. Too much going on there that a ton of practice would be required to do that without failure every time. On the other side, I have seen students choke when there's an empty mag still hanging out of the magwell in an AR. But we can train what to do if that does occur. Even if we master the reload, we still haven't touched on the recoil and the trigger pull.
Yes, I had very little time on this platform. I didn't have any time to "master" my reloads and I am not Travis Haley nor do I have his budget. I would say I can adapt very quickly to a lot of small arms but I don't think anyone can argue that it is not up to speed with the AR.

MountainRaven
07-01-13, 19:09
Jack is exactly correct. Too much going on there that a ton of practice would be required to do that without failure every time. On the other side, I have seen students choke when there's an empty mag still hanging out of the magwell in an AR. But we can train what to do if that does occur. Even if we master the reload, we still haven't touched on the recoil and the trigger pull.
Yes, I had very little time on this platform. I didn't have any time to "master" my reloads and I am not Travis Haley nor do I have his budget. I would say I can adapt very quickly to a lot of small arms but I don't think anyone can argue that it is not up to speed with the AR.

Not sure what you're getting at about Travis Haley. The gun doesn't belong to him or HSP. It was brought by one of the students. It took Travis five minutes to get the reload down under a second... having just picked up the weapon for the first time that day.

CoryCop25
07-01-13, 19:15
Not sure what you're getting at about Travis Haley. The gun doesn't belong to him or HSP. It was brought by one of the students. It took Travis five minutes to get the reload down under a second... having just picked up the weapon for the first time that day.

What I meant was I don't shoot or teach firearms insruction for a living. That should answer both parts of your post.

MountainRaven
07-01-13, 20:25
What I meant was I don't shoot or teach firearms insruction for a living. That should answer both parts of your post.

Understood.

Vitor
07-02-13, 10:46
The issue with the Tavor recoil has nothing to do with being a bullpup, it is due to the massivei BCG that has a long stroke operation. The piston is short but super thick, very different from the long and thin piston from the FN2k that has a quite smooth recoil.

sentinel
07-07-13, 17:42
For those wanting a better trigger for their Tavor be patient , A prototype has been developed and by accounts will soon be in the testing stage. It appears that this will consist of a drop-in module, refer to the following.

http://bullpupforum.com/index.php?topic=3194.100

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zHa8AqD7OpQ

Vitor
07-09-13, 20:09
For those wanting a better trigger for their Tavor be patient , A prototype has been developed and by accounts will soon be in the testing stage. It appears that this will consist of a drop-in module, refer to the following.

http://bullpupforum.com/index.php?topic=3194.100

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zHa8AqD7OpQ

Nice,the guy is claiming under 5lbs pull, this is quite a feat for a bullpup.

SteveS
07-13-13, 14:48
I would love to shoot one . But it is hard to beat a quality AR or AK for the $$$$

Ick
07-15-13, 11:30
For those wanting a better trigger for their Tavor be patient , A prototype has been developed and by accounts will soon be in the testing stage. It appears that this will consist of a drop-in module, refer to the following.

http://bullpupforum.com/index.php?topic=3194.100

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zHa8AqD7OpQ

Awesome.

signkutter
07-15-13, 21:35
The issue with the Tavor recoil has nothing to do with being a bullpup, it is due to the massivei BCG that has a long stroke operation. The piston is short but super thick, very different from the long and thin piston from the FN2k that has a quite smooth recoil.

Exactly. I found the recoil on the FN2K more manageable than the Tavor. The AUG3 recoil was more tame also and the AUG stock trigger was at least as good as the Tavor's after having been altered, After about 30 minutes and $70 dollars worth of hardware the AUG trigger can be a 5 lb , 1/4 inch overall travel snapper.

The Tavor shows alot of promise and I would purchase one , but as it stands now I prefer not only the M-4 to it... but also the FN2K and the AUG3

vicious_cb
08-05-13, 06:45
A lot of people seem to comment on how the mag release is awkward and inefficient. I'm also wondering how much of a snag hazard the trigger style mag release is. It seems that when letting the rifle hang, you would have a good chance of tripping the mag release on gear especially if you were moving.

If the mag release wasn't a problem then why did they change the location to the M4 FOW location in the X95 version of the Tavor?

http://www.israel-weapon.com/files/WEAPON/X95/X95%20FLATTOP/X95%20FLAT-TOP_327x218.jpg

Failure2Stop
08-05-13, 07:19
If the mag release wasn't a problem then why did they change the location to the M4 FOW location in the X95 version of the Tavor?

http://www.israel-weapon.com/files/WEAPON/X95/X95%20FLATTOP/X95%20FLAT-TOP_327x218.jpg

That's kinda neat actually.

MountainRaven
08-05-13, 08:29
A lot of people seem to comment on how the mag release is awkward and inefficient. I'm also wondering how much of a snag hazard the trigger style mag release is. It seems that when letting the rifle hang, you would have a good chance of tripping the mag release on gear especially if you were moving.

If the mag release wasn't a problem then why did they change the location to the M4 FOW location in the X95 version of the Tavor?

http://www.israel-weapon.com/files/WEAPON/X95/X95%20FLATTOP/X95%20FLAT-TOP_327x218.jpg

Probably because it's what the Israeli SOF who helped design the X95 wanted. (Just like how FNH kept switching the safety-selector back and forth on the SCAR between the 45- and 90 degree throw.)

I assume that if the mag release on the TAR were a problem that IWI would have modified it to be more like the X95 or ceased production entirely in favor of the X95 and X95 variants. But they haven't and the IDF (and other forces) still use the TAR.

dtibbals
08-12-13, 16:22
Not sure what you're getting at about Travis Haley. The gun doesn't belong to him or HSP. It was brought by one of the students. It took Travis five minutes to get the reload down under a second... having just picked up the weapon for the first time that day.

Yup I was there in class when Travis played with it. He seemed to like it but he was very clear that he would need a lot more time to make a decision on if it is worth having or not.

96 SS
08-12-13, 20:01
I keep hoping they will bring the X95 design over.

MountainRaven
08-12-13, 20:03
I keep hoping they will bring the X95 design over.

Word from IWI is 2015, at the soonest.

bohemian
08-14-13, 19:58
Had my tavor out for the second time (only fired about 50 rounds through it first day) and did this reload on the second attempt:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BF_RCFkkrgY

I'm not experienced with shooting to be honest. I wasn't trying to shoot fast, just reload fast. This gun is just plain easy to use and I think its quicker than the AR with regards to reloads (IMO only) If I had practiced for an hour or so Im sure I could have cut that time down much more.

This is the Canadian Tavor if that means anything.

SamM
11-10-13, 01:57
My review of the Tavor would be the opposite of this one. I love my Tavor and have owned it since May. I've become fairly fast with it. Yes, the drills are different but a little time is all that's needed. I have yet to experience any type of malfunction with it. Overall, I like it better than every other rifle of this type and I have owned all of them. It's easy to use due to it's compactness. It's much easier to manipulate that an AR or AK. Mine has proven to be very accurate as well. Much more accurate than my AUG/A3 was and the trigger is better. All the flap over the trigger is unfounded. Remove the reset spring, done. A Geissele trigger will only make this rifle better. It's been the only rifle that carries my ELCAN SpecterDR sight well, due to the weight being further back than most rifles. The combination of the Tavor and ELCAN is lethal, even at long-range distances. My LWRCI M6IC is now my backup rifle.

SamM