PDA

View Full Version : SR15 Carbine Mod 1 vs Carbine SBR



Amur
09-11-13, 20:08
I know they are both sweet and very similar.

SBR has mid contour ball dimpled 14.5" barrel
Mod 1 has thin profile 16" barrel

Do they have the exact same gas system?

The 14.5 weights slightl more which I am assuming is because the heavier barrel profile.

Any other differances?
I would just pin the 14.5 at this point but lets not get into that for now.
Is ther a favorite from the KAC crowd?

They are obviously very similar.

Which was has a slight edge in awesomeness?
Thanks

nml
09-11-13, 20:15
Keep in mind the stamp would take ****ing forever

Amur
09-11-13, 20:23
Keep in mind the stamp would take ****ing forever

I would just pick a MD....(maybe a MAMS) and pin it.

Tzook
09-11-13, 21:39
I can't speak to the SBR, but the 16 inch gun is crazy, crazy smooth.

mtdawg169
09-12-13, 15:49
I know they are both sweet and very similar.

SBR has mid contour ball dimpled 14.5" barrel
Mod 1 has thin profile 16" barrel

Do they have the exact same gas system?

The 14.5 weights slightl more which I am assuming is because the heavier barrel profile.

Any other differances?
I would just pin the 14.5 at this point but lets not get into that for now.
Is ther a favorite from the KAC crowd?

They are obviously very similar.

Which was has a slight edge in awesomeness?
Thanks

Same gas system length. Only difference is the barrel. E-man930 has one and can probably give you more insight into the differences between it and the Mod1. The carbine is definitely more unique due to the ball milled barrel.

E-man930
09-12-13, 19:40
14.5" Carbine is heavier, shoots about the same. I would say the recoil impulse of the 14.5" is just a hair "softer-quicker" feeling than the 16" version. I like mine because the barrel profile does aid accuracy, and for me it fills a void in between my bang-a-bullet 11.5" SBR and my 16" LMT 7.62 MWSE. I was able to get .82 MOA out of the 14.5" Carbine before the barrel started heating up. Hope this helps...

E-man930
09-12-13, 19:43
Which was has a slight edge in awesomeness?
Thanks

Whoops I forgot to answer the most important question! Of course the 14.5" Carbine is moar-full of awesomeness-ess!

trauma
09-12-13, 20:00
Big deciding factor for me was price.....Mod1 was 1950 and the 14.5 was 1700-1875. So a little bit more for a KAC ambi lower is worth the stretch.....

I just saw a used KAC lower sell on Gunbroker for over 1100.

With all that being said, I have 3 SR15's and will buy every damn thing these guys make, so I just haven't gotten around to buying the KAC 11.5 Gen 2 and 3 and the 14.5....

hjmpanzr
09-12-13, 21:58
I have two KAC 14.5 uppers and another complete SR-15 carbine on the way (as well as a KAC 11.5 SBR CQB).

I used to have sr-15 16" rifles, but I sold them earlier this year after getting my first KAC 14.5 upper. i had to fund all to fund those listed above.

As far as Im concerned the KAC 14.5 carbine is just about the best factory arrangement being offered in the 5.56 market.

jbo723
09-13-13, 06:59
I have two KAC 14.5 uppers and another complete SR-15 carbine on the way (as well as a KAC 11.5 SBR CQB).

I used to have sr-15 16" rifles, but I sold them earlier this year after getting my first KAC 14.5 upper. i had to fund all to fund those listed above.

As far as Im concerned the KAC 14.5 carbine is just about the best factory arrangement being offered in the 5.56 market.

I own a couple of 16" SR15's and have a few hundred rounds through the 14.5 SR15 with a MAMS and with a SF MB556. If you like a little more weight up front, then the 14.5 is pretty hard to beat. It's the flattest shooting carbine I've every personally shot.

The 16" just feels a little bit lighter at the muzzle but, shoots just as smooth. Obviously can't go wrong with either so, the decision is whether or not you want to pin a FH/MB on the 14.5, wait through the NFA process if you can even find a factory 14.5" carbine, or grab a 16" that would probably be more readily available.

I do plan on eventually adding one to my collection but, that would be awhile since I already have (2) 14.5's that I've been running and it would really just be redundant to add another at this time.

Amur
09-13-13, 08:54
I just ordered a 14.5 with pinned MAMS. At the very least it is one of the most unique pieces out there.

Can't wait to get my hands on it.

As soon as I move to a state that allows suppresors I see a KAC QD mini in my future....

Failure2Stop
09-13-13, 09:37
I just ordered a 14.5 with pinned MAMS. At the very least it is one of the most unique pieces out there.

Can't wait to get my hands on it.


From who?


Typos brought to you via Tapatalk and autocorrect.

Amur
09-13-13, 10:02
From who?


Typos brought to you via Tapatalk and autocorrect.

Kylesgunshop

Amur
09-13-13, 10:03
From who?


Typos brought to you via Tapatalk and autocorrect.

BTW: what's your take on the 14.5 with dimpled barrel?

Breacher 217
09-13-13, 12:49
I've got a few 16" KAC guns but have a 14.5 and additional MAMS on order. I will probably be selling one of my 16" uppers once the 14.5 comes in this month. The 14.5 will be getting the MAMS pinned.

Mak8080
09-14-13, 01:05
I give the slight edge to the 14.5" versus the 16". A bit heavier, but a very soft shooter. I have been thinking about chopping my 16" to 14.5" and see what that feels like.

Huskyfever03
09-14-13, 11:56
I just ordered a 14.5 with pinned MAMS.

Smart man :D
http://i18.photobucket.com/albums/b112/huskyfever03/32537631-029F-491B-8532-4E5FED8BEE81-33178-000008F586E1A95A_zps9e1d4bfc.jpg
http://i18.photobucket.com/albums/b112/huskyfever03/8EA07120-BF18-4363-8275-DB885FBD4A8D-33451-000008F6454625AF_zpsed0ca5c6.jpg

Boba Fett v2
09-14-13, 13:30
I just went with the 16". Didn't want to wait forever and pay extra for a an inch and a half, but that's just me. The barrel dimples on the 14.5" are nice though...

I think the 16" is just as sexy.

http://imageshack.us/a/img543/9100/i8mv.jpg