PDA

View Full Version : Because All Nazi's Weren't Bad...



SteyrAUG
05-12-17, 02:59
Figured I'd get some of the hijack out of the other threads.

Oskar Schindler was a member of the nazi party (NSDAP) and decided to help people rather than continue to get rich. He was named Righteous Among the Nations by the Israeli government in 1963. He died on 9 October 1974 in Hildesheim, Germany, and was buried in Jerusalem on Mount Zion, the only member of the Nazi Party to be honoured in this way.

There was the German officer in "The Pianist" who we must assume is a real person, who may or may not have been a member of the NSDAP.

John Rabe was a NSDAP member who is best known for his efforts to stop the atrocities of the Japanese army during the Nanking Occupation and his work to protect and help the Chinese civilians during the event. The Nanking Safety Zone, which he helped to establish, sheltered approximately 200,000 Chinese people from slaughter during the massacre.

Wernher von Braun was a member of the NSDAP and we'd have never made it to the moon without him. We should keep in mind if you had any political aspirations and ideas of advancement in Germany at the time you pretty much had to join the party, they even ran the post office which was nationalized. Braun did benefit from slave labor but I think we wanted to go to the moon really, really badly so it was mostly overlooked.

There were also dozens of other rocket scientists, physicists and similar types involved in advanced weapons programs for the Nazi's and we pretty much gave them a pass (see: paperclip) in exchange for their data and work. This is pretty tame compared to the deal we cut with those in charge of Unit 731 in Manchuria.

We should also remember when it comes to the SS there were several branches, the waffen SS, the SD and the Gestapo for example. While many people assert that the Waffen SS is fundamentally no different from the Wehrmacht that isn't completely true. They were known to engage in atrocities from time to time such as the Malmedy massacre by the 1st SS Panzer Division, 1944, Belgium.

It's true that there are members of the Waffen SS who never engaged in such acts and even entire units who never participated in such actions, but it is disingenuous to suggest none of them ever did and they were just another branch of the military.

And there are countless stories of individuals and even small groups who helped save victims who were being persecuted by the NSDAP. Indeed the first concentration camp at Dachau was designed to hold Germans who objected to the actions of the nazi leadership, including the treatment of jews, gypsies, slavs and other undesirables.

As Heydrich himself lamented at Wanssee "Every German seems to know at least one good jew." So there you have it, even in a totalitarian state such as Hitlers Germany where helping "enemies of the state" could actually get you killed, there were still people who decided they couldn't stand by and do nothing and even members of the party were willing to risk their lives to help people they determined were innocent.

Of course the big problem is for every Oskar Schindler there was a Joseph Mengele who not only killed victims in camps but engaged in truly sadistic medical experiments with his human subjects. And there were legions of the Allgemeine SS who were absolutely devoted to the mandate of Hitler, Himmler and Heydrich and were represented by the SS-Totenkopfverbände which managed the concentration camps and other units like the Einsatzgruppen which functioned as death squads when the military invaded new territory.

And it is those guys who generally give the nazis and the SS a bad name, despite the Schindlers, Rabes and other "good Germans" who happen to be members of the NSDAP for whatever reason.

Moose-Knuckle
05-12-17, 03:57
Oh boy now you went and done it.

The knee jerk reactionary "OMG M4C is Stormfront" members will now have a complete and obligatory conniption fit. :lol:


Wernher Magnus Maximilian Freiherr von Braun has got to be on the top of the list. Himmler "urged" him to join the SS. Von Braun consulted his superior officer Dr. Dornberger and told him that if he wanted to continue to work on the rocket program he would have to join.

But we gave asylum to far more sinister characters than that via Operation Paperclip after the war.

Then there was Lauri Allan Törni who as a Finn help defeat the Soviets when they invaded his homeland, later joined the SS and fought for the reich against the allies, and eventually became a Major in US Army Special Forces.

Honu
05-12-17, 05:14
good write up :)




Nazi party like the democrats (socialist) sadly very close these days

the SS was the armed division of course much like the ultra radical left of the democrats(socialist) today doing the major harm and rioting maybe examples of the soros funded groups etc..

basically much again like the liberal media and so on today youtube being a good example if you run a very conservative channel you will get defunded etc..
the media taking marching orders ?

kinda scary to see so much of the history repeating itself and yet they are the ones of course calling us the Nazi ! ? but then again the brown shirts of the day did the same thing as what is happening today being sent out to cities well funded to cause havoc etc..


I feel we are now the majority of Germans in Germany at the time of starting to go OK whats going on and are we going to let it go on ? and not saying we are there yet but if the left has its way the socialists of course once again will strike


the silent majority has to stand up this time !

yoni
05-12-17, 05:26
"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing."

My fear from such a post is that we might in the minds of some reading it lessen the evil of the Nazi's.

If you changed it to say not all Germans were totally evil, that would sit better with me.

Honu hit some great points, we are watching the progressives steal the media, take to the streets with violence. Yet we seem in capable to stop them, so by default we are doing that nothing the Burke spoke of.

I include myself in this, so how are we any different from the good Germans that allowed the National Socialist to take over?

Pilot1
05-12-17, 05:32
The very poor economic situation in Germany helped propel the Nazis to power. No, it is not an excuse, but I don't think the average German anticipated what was going to eventually happen.

Eurodriver
05-12-17, 06:09
The knee jerk reactionary "OMG M4C is Stormfront" members will now have a complete and obligatory conniption fit. :lol:


You don't see a problem with a forum you are associated with having a "Because All Nazi's Weren't Bad" thread? I understand some old guy with no aspirations who hasn't got much to lose wouldn't really give a ****, but this has gotten out of control lately. Sensei already popped smoke and I have talked to a few other members who will be soon as well. I can't risk my reputation being associated with a bunch of retards who think defending Nazism (even in the context of Steyr's thread - which I understand isn't a defense of Nazism but remain unsure exactly what his point is) is acceptable in any way, shape, or form.

This is embarrassing. There were over a million SS members during WWII, and over eight million Nazi Party members. Those two organizations were responsible for the Holocaust, and because Steyr made a post naming like six people who were decent and "dozens more" that were merely forgiven for their transgressions in a bid to help us defeat the Soviets at engineering rockets we are cool with the SS now?

Nah fam.

"Germany during the Nazi period was inhabited by people animated by beliefs about Jews that made them willing to become consenting mass executioners. The study of the perpetrators, especially of police battalions, who were a representative cross section of German men - and therefore are indicative of what ordinary Germans were like regarding Jews - compels us, precisely because they were representative of Germans to draw this conclusion about the German people. Being ordinary in the Germany that gave itself to Nazism was to have been a member of an extraordinary, lethal political culture. That German political culture was producing such voluntarism killers suggests, in turn, that perhaps this was a society that had undergone other important and fundamental changes, particularly cognitive and moral ones."

- Hitler's Willing Executioners - Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust, p.455-456

I've read Police Battalion 101 (pretty much the antithesis of this book) and it's horseshit. The German people were ingrained to hate Jews. The "good" Germans were like Abraham Lincoln - he freed the slaves but still thought blacks were subhuman, dirty, and sure as shit didn't want his sons marrying any of them.

I wish I could find a very compelling picture of thousands of Germans attending a rally with a huge banner that read "Exterminate the Jews". There must have been 10,000+ people at this rally. The purpose was to find out how to rid Germany of the Jews.

The picture was taken in the 1890s.

Big A
05-12-17, 07:39
You don't see a problem with a forum you are associated with having a "Because All Nazi's Weren't Bad" thread? I understand some old guy with no aspirations who hasn't got much to lose wouldn't really give a ****, but this has gotten out of control lately. Sensei already popped smoke and I have talked to a few other members who will be soon as well. I can't risk my reputation being associated with a bunch of retards who think defending Nazism (even in the context of Steyr's thread - which I understand isn't a defense of Nazism but remain unsure exactly what his point is) is acceptable in any way, shape, or form.

This is embarrassing. There were over a million SS members during WWII, and over eight million Nazi Party members. Those two organizations were responsible for the Holocaust, and because Steyr made a post naming like six people who were decent and "dozens more" that were merely forgiven for their transgressions in a bid to help us defeat the Soviets at engineering rockets we are cool with the SS now?

Nah fam.

"Germany during the Nazi period was inhabited by people animated by beliefs about Jews that made them willing to become consenting mass executioners. The study of the perpetrators, especially of police battalions, who were a representative cross section of German men - and therefore are indicative of what ordinary Germans were like regarding Jews - compels us, precisely because they were representative of Germans to draw this conclusion about the German people. Being ordinary in the Germany that gave itself to Nazism was to have been a member of an extraordinary, lethal political culture. That German political culture was producing such voluntarism killers suggests, in turn, that perhaps this was a society that had undergone other important and fundamental changes, particularly cognitive and moral ones."

- Hitler's Willing Executioners - Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust, p.455-456

I've read Police Battalion 101 (pretty much the antithesis of this book) and it's horseshit. The German people were ingrained to hate Jews. The "good" Germans were like Abraham Lincoln - he freed the slaves but still thought blacks were subhuman, dirty, and sure as shit didn't want his sons marrying any of them.

I wish I could find a very compelling picture of thousands of Germans attending a rally with a huge banner that read "Exterminate the Jews". There must have been 10,000+ people at this rally. The purpose was to find out how to rid Germany of the Jews.

The picture was taken in the 1890s.

Agreed. It's getting weird around here lately. Thankfully that one member finally got banned, but stuff like this where someone on the internet could just come across the thread title and make this forum and gun owners in general out to be Nazi sympathizers is just bad form.

I get what you're driving at here Steyr. Some folks like Schindler had to make a decision about self preservation when his whole country changed around him to something completely different. Join or Die in 1930's Germany doesn't have the same connotation as it did in 1776 Colonial America.

And **** Von Braun. His V2 rockets killed thousands of innocent civilians. After we got all the intelligence we could glean from him he should have received a 30-06 lobotomy. Or at least been given to the Brits to face justice.

Outlander Systems
05-12-17, 08:00
This is un****ingbelievable.