Crossbreed vs. Comp-Tac Minotaur IWB?

[boondocksaint]

Anybody worn both of these IWB holsters?

I have a Crossbreed for my Glock 23 and find it very comfortable, but the Comp-Tac looks to be a bit more "finished". I may try a Comp-Tac for my XD, as I love the idea of being able to swap out the kydex bodies for diff. guns.

Thoughts good or bad on the extra leather on the body side of the holster? Depending on the thickness, I could see it being a bit bulky...

[maximus83]

I've not tried both, but I considered both and went with a CrossBreed initially on the features that were available at the time I purchased. One comparative point I've heard in the past, some have said that Crossbreed used inferior material in their clips. However, they have upgraded in the last year and provide steel clips now, so this probably no longer applies. In any case, I think the Comp-Tac is a great holster too, and it's probably just a choice of which one you think has the features that will work for you.

Can't tell you which is better, but can report that I've had good success with my CrossBreed IWB (it's for my M&P9, and BTW, it not only fits ALL sizes of the M&P 9--the long, the full-size, and the compact--it also fits my M&P 45 mid-size). It is very comfortable for an IWB, gives good retention, and is useful because it fits so many pistols in the M&P series. It's also great for concealment. I got the one where you can attach the clips to a velcro strip on the inside of your belt, so that the clips are completely hidden and you can actually tuck a shirt over it if you want. It worked great for me when I used it, although recently I've reverted to carrying mostly OWB. For me, the Crossbreed is a fine holster, but I'm finding that when I can, I prefer to go with traditional OWB mode of carry.

[BAC]

I have only carried the Crossbreed, and only using a little Bersa 380. This combo, by the way, makes the gun disappear and is stupidly comfortable (shame I can't warm up to the Bersa). I'm very curious how well the leather/kydex combo carries a heavier gun like a full-sized 1911, or at the very least a full-sized polymer-framed gun.


-B

[LDM]

I own two Comp-Tac Minotaur holsters and have a third on order, so it goes without saying I've been pleased with their product and service
Everything I've read about Crossbred is favorable and I looked at their web page before ordering Comp-Tac #3.
One big difference is that you can change the kydex bodies on the Comp-Tac for another weapon. You just buy a different kydex shell and change out the old for the new. I have done this and it works well. I stand to be corrected, but it appears to me the Crossbreed is hard riveted and their web site does not indicate you can change bodies.
I carry a HK 2000 and a SIG 220 SAO in my Comp-Tacs and it does a great job with these two not-so-small weapons. Before, I had a 1911 shell, and it really does a great job with that weapon.
The one on order is for a Kahr PM9. I am pretty sure the Comp-Tac will make the PM9 disappear.
Stay safe.

[maximus83]

I'm very curious how well the leather/kydex combo carries a heavier gun like a full-sized 1911, or at the very least a full-sized polymer-framed gun.


Good question. To check it out, just now I put on the Crossbreed, holstered the M&P9 Pro (which has roughly the same height, length, and width as a 1911), and tried a range of movements and sitting positions. It is virtually as comfortable and concealable with the big Pro model riding in the holster, as it is with the compact. Only slight difference is, if you shift a certain way while seated in a soft cushioned chair or car seat, you may feel the muzzle a bit. But really, I think I'd have no problem carrying the Pro this way. So I'd guess a similar-size 1911 Govt model would also work.

[boondocksaint]

LDM,

Your are correct. The Crossbreed holster has the kydex body hard riveted in place. That's one of the features I really like about (at least in theory, as I haven't bought one yet) the Comp-Tac.

Right now, I carry my Glock 23 in my Crossbreed and have worn it in several different vehicles (duty and personal) and love the way it hides my gun. I used to use one of the Uncle Mike's neoprene IWB holsters and I was always checking it to make sure the belt clip wasn't coming up over my belt. I haven't had any such worries at all with my Crossbreed.

As I stated before, I like the looks of the Comp-Tac and will most likely be getting one for my XD sub-compact.

Be safe.

[mattpittinger]

OP:
I have used both holsters for a little over a year carrying various Glocks, M&Ps, and 1911s. The Comp-Tac has my vote. The Cross Breed is a good holster, but I feel that it lacks the finish of the Comp-Tac. Also if you are a gun slut like me, you will love the interchangeable bodies.

[boondocksaint]

OP:
I Also if you are a gun slut like me, you will love the interchangeable bodies.

Guilty. My wife will often reminds me to remove my "gun porn" catalogs from the table, as she is trying to clean, etc.... :D

Thanks for the input.

[Alpha Sierra]

Having owned both makes, Comp-Tac products are a cut above anything from Crossbreed.

[maximus83]

If I were buying another IWB, I have to admit the feature of being able to switch out the Kydex holster body for only about $38, so you can use with another pistol, is pretty appealing.

[unclestevie45]

I own both. The Comp-Tac is by far a better holster. The retention is better, the finish better.

COmfort is comparable.

[boondocksaint]

I appreciate all the input. I know in the end, holsters are an item that really boil down to personal tastes/comfort, etc.

Comp-Tac has a 10% off deal through Dec, and I may try to order one.

Thanks! Merry Christmas!

[lomp64]

Good question. To check it out, just now I put on the Crossbreed, holstered the M&P9 Pro (which has roughly the same height, length, and width as a 1911), and tried a range of movements and sitting positions. It is virtually as comfortable and concealable with the big Pro model riding in the holster, as it is with the compact. Only slight difference is, if you shift a certain way while seated in a soft cushioned chair or car seat, you may feel the muzzle a bit. But really, I think I'd have no problem carrying the Pro this way. So I'd guess a similar-size 1911 Govt model would also work.

I have carried for the past 8 months or so a full size 1911 (kimber warrior) in a comp-tac minotaur. Works excellently, it supports the weight and is very comfortable. The only thing I did notice was the finish on the side that was rubbing against the leather was getting worn a little. Now this doesn't much matter to me but it may to others.

[restfortheweary]

I have both and you can't go wrong with either. I think the clips on the crossbreed are more stable; however, I like the modularity of the Comp-tac. I regularly use the Comp-tac for my Gov't 1911 and the crossbreed for my glocks.

[Spade]

I currently carry an XD .45 service model in a Crossbread supertuck. The only complaints I have is that the rear clip tends come un clipped from my belt when sitting which can be annoying. I also busted one of the clips. However I replaced both clips with metal ones & have had much less issues.

[ChicagoTex]

I used to have two Crossbreed SuperTucks for my Kahr P40 and Glock 26, carried one or the other every day for 2 years.

The P40 one was the standard variant, without the "Combat Cut", as it broke in it started hitting the admittedly sticking-way-too-far-out mag release on the P40 during normal carry, that got real old, real fast - dumped the holster and the gun.

The Glock one has the combat cut, so no unintended mag releases, but the plastic clips have bent out of shape. It's not a deal-breaker, but it definetely looks and feel crappy. I traded the G26, but I'm keeping the holster around until I decide whether I'm gonna pick up a Glock 17 before I sell it outright.

Since then, Crossbreed has switched to steel clips, which people claim are better. The new clips are a total deal breaker for me and I absolutely, positively, will not give another dime to Crossbreed unless and until they dump the moronic cross-cutout on their clips. They're far too garish for what's supposed a subtle carry solution, they seem likely to catch on any number of things, and as a non-Christian I really have no interest parading around with another religion's iconography on my hip.

Next time I'll go with Comp-Tac, they're better made, made much more quickly, and designed by people who are actually interested in practicality instead of "spreading the gospel" through gunleather... :rolleyes:

[Mark/MO]

I have not used a Comp-Tac holster but from what I have heard are great holsters. I bought a Crossbreed IWB holster a few months ago and have been happy with it so far. I am fairly new to CCW and have only tried three or four holsters. The Crossbreed is the favorite of my admittedly small pool.

By looking at the posts Crossbreed appears to have made some changes. My Crossbreed is very comfortable and seems quite thin. Mine has metal clips that are very secure. So secure that it takes me a moment or so to get it off. There’s no "cutout" on my clips but there is a small embossed cross. Not very noticeable and it doesn't bother me, but to each his own. As I said before the Comp-Tac is supposed to be very good and the interchangeability feature would be nice. Either should serve well.

[nipplehead]

Having owned both makes, Comp-Tac products are a cut above anything from Crossbreed.


I also have both and I agree Comptac is better. I bought the crossbreed because comptac did not make a holster for the HK45. Almost all other pistols I carry have a comptac including the 5.7

[William B.]

I have only carried the Crossbreed, and only using a little Bersa 380. This combo, by the way, makes the gun disappear and is stupidly comfortable (shame I can't warm up to the Bersa). I'm very curious how well the leather/kydex combo carries a heavier gun like a full-sized 1911, or at the very least a full-sized polymer-framed gun.


-B

I carry a full-sized SW1911PD in a Crossbreed Supertuck. The holster works perfectly. I've never carried with my shirt tucked in around the gun because it looks awful as well as obvious, but under an untucked shirt or a jacket I never even know it's there.

[Shawn.L]

Im thinking of ordering a MTAC for an IWB option on my 1911. There site says they are doing some design changes on the 1911 models.

wonder what those will be.....

[HES]

One big difference is that you can change the kydex bodies on the Comp-Tac for another weapon. You just buy a different kydex shell and change out the old for the new. I have done this and it works well.
And this is the main reason I went to the Comp-TAC Minotaur as well. Comfortable a all get out with good retention. I have carried a 1911, Beretta PX4, XD(m), and an M&P. In all 4 cases I was extremely happy. It is very comfortable. Heck I've driven from Tampa to Charlotte wearing it and didnt complain once.

Having said that the crossbreed may be just as comfortable and offer retention just as good or better. I can't say as I have never worn one.

I think in the end no matter which choice you may you will not be disappointed. It just comes down to your personal preference.