PDA

View Full Version : My Streamlight TLR-1 Review



Kilo6
05-24-10, 19:55
I know that this light has been out for a while but I just wanted to share my thoughts. Thanks for looking.

Heavy-duty, compact, and great design are the thoughts that run through my mind upon un-boxing it. It feels very solid in my hand. For some reason, my caveman instincts kick in and I instantly have the urge to bang it up against something hard to test its solidity. Its exterior is machined aluminum with a black anodized finish. A great feature is that it is designed with a glass and not a plastic lens. Its sealed construction is waterproof up to 1 meter for 30 minutes according to Streamlight’s website.
http://www.comentakeit.com/uploads/4/3/4/9/4349417/3786772.jpg?508

Mounting the light is simple thanks to its rail grip clamp system. The side screw appears to be counter-resistant with a wave spring. I am able to quickly mount it without placing my hand in front of the muzzle. It is secured in place by tightening down the thumb screw. No tools are needed to mount the light or to remove it. I find this very useful in regards to weapon takedown and quickly transitioning into a concealed carry role.
http://www.comentakeit.com/uploads/4/3/4/9/4349417/1207146.jpg?505

The actual light is bright white and not the yellowish incandescent color that you would see with older style flashlights that do not utilize LED technology. The light output is phenomenal and throws a flawless spill beam. Even at 25 feet, in a lit room, the peripheral illumination is optimal. At 7 yards, I have my wife give me a quick hit in the eyes in a lit up room. This little beast has no problem blinding me temporarily. I ask her if she wants to give it whirl, and she replies, “Not right now Hun”. How nice of her to take a rain check. Generally speaking, current battery technology isn’t the greatest. But when paired up with C4 LED technology, the TLR-1 has a run time of 2.5 hours and up to 135 lumens. There TLR-3 model produces 90 lumens but is also more compact and lighter.

MP15-22 Fun night plinking
http://www.comentakeit.com/uploads/4/3/4/9/4349417/1055092.jpg?504

In the field, while mounted on 9mm handgun, it performed flawlessly. Testing it while mounted on an AR15 produced zero malfunctions and it was impervious to shock. Transitioning from hand gun to rifle is no problem as it is capable of being mounted on 1913 picatinny rails. The ambidextrous momentary is very smooth while toggling. I have no problems going from momentary, steady on, and off using my strong-hand index finger. Unfortunately, this is most likely not the case under stress as the switch is capable of being toggled on from both sides. Because of this, one could easily make the mistake of trying to toggle it on by swiveling the switch to the momentary on position. Training is key here so practicing all settings, with gun safety in mind of course, is essential for proper deployment. The operation is simple enough, however, that once muscle memory is developed it becomes second nature.

Lastly, I have just a few negatives to report. I notice that during everyday normal rifle manipulation, accidental light discharge is more common than not. It happened to me twice, but could have been avoided with a secondary stand-alone off switch. The bright white lettering on the sides of the TLR-1 is a little flashy for my taste. A simple engraving of the logos and information into the aluminum housing would be sufficient and would give it that subdued look. A more flat finish would also help in avoiding the appearance of powder fouling that stains the top front of the light. I recommend placing a strip of tape over the top of it to avoid this while training. Some claim that the added weight is an issue. In my case, however, it does not throw off my balance and actually helps out my muzzle control. I opted for the non-laser TLR due to added price and simply because I prefer to use and train with sights.

Overall, the TLR-1 is a great target-identifying upgrade for my system.

At 15 feet
http://www.comentakeit.com/uploads/4/3/4/9/4349417/8964656.jpg?504

At 25 feet
http://www.comentakeit.com/uploads/4/3/4/9/4349417/4320482.jpg?504

Inner beam still solid at 35 feet
http://www.comentakeit.com/uploads/4/3/4/9/4349417/6515758.jpg?504

More G19/TLR-1/MP15-22 pics here G19/TLR/MP15-22 PICS (http://www.comentakeit.com/streamlight-tlr-1.html)

mskdgunman
05-25-10, 02:10
I couldn't agree more regarding the TLR-1. They are great little lights for the money. I currntly have three of them. One on my duty handgun, another on my shotgun and a third on my AR. The one on my AR is mounted on a rail attached to the bayonet lug (may as well use it for something) and I use a pigtail pressure switch. I have also experienced a few light related AD's on the rifle mounted light and agree that this is one of the lights drawbacks.

Kilo6
05-25-10, 14:43
And it seems like such an easy fix. Maybe we will see one on their next revision.

Six Feet Under
06-01-10, 22:40
I have owned two TLR-1's, the current C4 LED model and the old 90 lumen model.

Loved 'em both. I've forgotten to tighten the light down onto my G19's rail and when I pulled the trigger, had it go flying off and land five feet away on concrete with barely a small scratch on the corner of the light. I'd hope it could stand something like that repeatedly, but that definitely bolstered my confidence in its durability.

Dennis
06-02-10, 15:30
I have owned two TLR-1's, the current C4 LED model and the old 90 lumen model.

Loved 'em both. I've forgotten to tighten the light down onto my G19's rail and when I pulled the trigger, had it go flying off and land five feet away on concrete with barely a small scratch on the corner of the light. I'd hope it could stand something like that repeatedly, but that definitely bolstered my confidence in its durability.

I'm sorta biased towards lights that don't fly off my gun by default... :rolleyes:

Littlelebowski
06-02-10, 15:34
I'm sorta biased towards lights that don't fly off my gun by default... :rolleyes:

He said in plain English that he forgot to tighten it down.

JSantoro
06-02-10, 17:08
http://esl.about.com/

Victory
06-02-10, 18:54
I'm a fan of the TLR series of lights, too. I have a TLR-1 on my AR, and yes, I too find it easy to have a ND. The switch is very easy to depress. If Streamlight were to implement a lock-out switch, that would be great.

Here is how I set up my TLR-1 configuration:

http://img189.imageshack.us/img189/1818/tlr003.jpg

Streamlight offers an IR filter for the TLR series, which I'm using. It doesn't work very well as an IR flashlight, though, due to the C4 LED. The filter does work as a beam cover, though.

I don't fully trust the locking mechanism, hence the zip-tie on the light/DD mount. One of these days, I'll be preforming this modification:

http://www.weaponevolution.com/forum/showthread.php?1578-TLR1-Thumb-Nut-Modification.

The tape switches are of decent quality. It'd be nice if they were a little higher quality, but they work ok.

Overall, I'm very satisfied with the TLR series. I just ordered a TLR-1S for my shotgun from OpticsPlanet over the weekend. Can't wait to try out the strobe feature. The added 30 lumens should be nice, as well.

-Vic

Dennis
06-02-10, 19:40
He said in plain English that he forgot to tighten it down.


http://esl.about.com/

Ouch :p My actual point is that it takes a separate action to mount and tighten it, and it can still come loose as well. The SF X300 design is a bit more robust in that just snapping it on is more positive, an absolutely positive locking system is included, and a DG tailcap switch makes it even less likely to separate.

As always, regular PM of important equipment is the only way to live. :)

Dennis.

gumby223
06-09-10, 06:19
I've got the TLR1s, and must say that it is the best handgun weaponlight I've had to date. I highly recommend it.

decodeddiesel
06-12-10, 16:17
I'm a fan of the TLR series of lights, too. I have a TLR-1 on my AR, and yes, I too find it easy to have a ND. The switch is very easy to depress. If Streamlight were to implement a lock-out switch, that would be great.

Here is how I set up my TLR-1 configuration:

http://img189.imageshack.us/img189/1818/tlr003.jpg

Streamlight offers an IR filter for the TLR series, which I'm using. It doesn't work very well as an IR flashlight, though, due to the C4 LED. The filter does work as a beam cover, though.

I don't fully trust the locking mechanism, hence the zip-tie on the light/DD mount. One of these days, I'll be preforming this modification:

http://www.weaponevolution.com/forum/showthread.php?1578-TLR1-Thumb-Nut-Modification.

The tape switches are of decent quality. It'd be nice if they were a little higher quality, but they work ok.

Overall, I'm very satisfied with the TLR series. I just ordered a TLR-1S for my shotgun from OpticsPlanet over the weekend. Can't wait to try out the strobe feature. The added 30 lumens should be nice, as well.

-Vic

Wow, where did you get the rail mounted switch? Also, I didn't know they had a strobe model now. :cool: I must admit, I am also a big TLR-1 fan. I think for the money they just can't be beat.

As far as the mounting system, I greatly prefer the mounting system of the TLR to the X200-X300. Albeit, my only experience with Surefire lights is an X200A mounted on a Dawson rail, but still it's the same system. However it seems Surefire agrees as the X400 uses a similar mounting method to the TLR-1.

Victory
06-14-10, 02:54
http://www.opticsplanet.net/streamlight-plug-in-remote-switches-for-tlr-weapons-flashlights.html

"Streamlight LOng Gun Remote Tape Switch Plug, Straight"

It comes with the rail mounting clips and two screws for non-railed handguard mounting. Oh, and zip ties.

I bought it elsewhere, but I wouldn't reccomend them. I can reccomend Optics Planet, though. :D

-Vic