PDA

View Full Version : Yankee Hill vs. Daniel Defense vs. Noveske?


mwt1980
05-24-10, 23:04
Which one...Looking for a new upper? I assume any of them will work with my stag lower....correct?
500grains
05-24-10, 23:10
Which one...Looking for a new upper?

YH = OK, kind of sexy looking, but not true milspec or top drawer.

DD = excellent milspec quality

Noveske = absolutely top drawer.


I assume any of them will work with my stag lower....correct?

Yes.
lethal dose
05-24-10, 23:44
I assume you're talking about a complete upper? If so, dd or noveske. If it's just the reciever, it'd hardly make a difference. Just be certain you add a quality Bcg like a bcm or LMT. Personally, I'd go with an LMT complete upper... love mine.
scottd907
05-24-10, 23:50
Umm well thats a easy question to answer. Noveske is going to be your best bet when you compare it to just about any upper that isnt a piston system. But thats my IMO and iv only shot one of them, i own a Noveske upper that fits well with my RRA lower.

Im interested why you picked those three.

Theres a big price difference between all of them, starting with YHM being the cheapest and Noveske being most expensive.
lethal dose
05-24-10, 23:51
Not trying to be ignorant... but you probably could have searched and found a great answer. ;)
seb5
05-25-10, 07:19
Would you rather drive a Kia, a Ford. or a Porsche? They all get you there.
austinN4
05-25-10, 07:32
Which one...Looking for a new upper?
BMC should be considered - high quality at a reasonable cost. My choice would be be between BCM or Noveske.
Failure2Stop
05-25-10, 10:30
The M4C Mantra:

What do you want it to do and how much are you willing to spend?
mwt1980
05-25-10, 18:26
Ended up buying a new complete DD rifle w/ the Omega X rail. Gonna put my X300 at high noon and mount my XPS2 -0. BOOYA!

Look out bugs and zombies!

Oh the pain of CA's 10 day waiting period.
scottd907
05-25-10, 22:29
great choice. I hardly see anyone complaining about their DD rifle.
texag
05-25-10, 23:38
great choice. I hardly see anyone complaining about their DD rifle.

Mine seems to devour all ammo in its presence. Gets expensive.
ra2bach
05-26-10, 09:18
The M4C Mantra:

What do you want it to do and how much are you willing to spend?

amen. this type of question makes as much sense as "do you walk to school or carry your lunch?"...
Falkon
05-26-10, 10:12
I've been absolutley satisfied with my DD Middy complete. Only 320 rounds down range, but not one single issue whatsoever with several different brands of ammo.