PDA

View Full Version : AAR: Insights Training Center - General Defensive Rifle 6/26/2010



Jeff_M
07-11-10, 15:02
http://www.insightstraining.com/blog/

We conducted our two day General Defensive Rifle Course in Ravensdale, WA at Cascade Shooting Facilities on June 26 and 27. This is a great facility that we use for our Intermediate Defensive Rifle course and more advanced handgun courses, but it is the first time we used it for GDR.
http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-20.jpg

Both days we had perfect weather (there is no better place than the Pacific Northwest in the summer). In the mornings it was slightly cloudy and then sunny in the afternoons with highs in the 70s.

The class was mostly regular folks with one cop and a sailor. There was a mix of experience and skill. Some folks were new to defensive rifle work and others came to the course with an excellent foundation of skill.

As always, we started the morning off with a discussion of the Universal Firearms Handling Rules and then moved on to discuss our CQM shooting platform, aiming, and trigger control. We also covered two of the most common problems in our rifle courses: lubrication and magazines. Lots of lube and only 28 rounds in the mags! The magazine issue became a problem for some later.

Additionally, we clarified the intent of the course. This is not fantasy camp. Our goal is to provide students with the foundational mindset, tactics, and skills for the defensive use of the carbine/rifle in a violent confrontation. We keep things simple and weave this theme into all aspects of our training.
http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-17.jpg
We were able to progress very quickly through most of the gun handling and some basic close quarters markmanship in the morning. After lunch we covered zeroing the rifle and confirmed our zeros at 25 and 50 yards. We then covered position shooting, pivots, and movement. After day one, we had completed our goal of covering most of the skills and techniques in isolation. This provides us with a foundation for a successful day two and more complex drills.

The morning of day two we covered pieing corners and delibrate one man clearing of a room. We then moved to the range and shot around barricades from varying positions. We continued with more advanced gun handling and marksmanship drills. We then pushed back to 100 yards and shot varying positions on steel. In the middle of the afternoon we discussed wound ballistics and terminal effects of rifle cartridges. We ended the day by covering dynamic movement and combining many of our skills into some pretty fun drills.

Lessons learned: The skills we teach fit together in a systematic way. Some of the students found this out the hard way. Sometimes it is a process of unlearning the old and embracing the new. Unfortunately some come to class with ingrained ways of running a rifle and it can be a frustrating process trying to unlearn improper procedures and techniques. Sometimes it is as simple as what direction do your mags face while mounted on your belt and why. Do you have your gear setup a particular way just because you’ve always done it like that? Is it because you saw it on TV or a video? Or do you have a reasoned well thought out systematic way of setting up your gear that provides for efficient and consistent techniques.

Overall, the students picked up the material quickly, and we were able to progress through the curriculum a little faster than normal. Toward the end of day two, a few students who only brought the required minimum were running low on ammo. In the end there were no issues and we worked through it. However, keep in mind that you should always consider the listed equipment requirements MINIMUMS. If I take a course I bring at least 150% of the required ammo and typically 200%. It is similar with mags. 10 AR mags is a minimum for me and 20 is typical.

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-8.jpg

We had mostly ARs in the class. All seemed to run well when lubed, even the piston guns (there’s a first). There was a SCAR which did not have any problems as expected. There was one AK. While this platform can be an excellent defensive rifle, the operator quickly found out many of its short comings regarding ergonomics and gunhandling. In my mind an AK is a great answer for a cheap detachable magazine semi auto rifle in the $250 to $400 range. However, if you are going to spend the money for a fancy AK, then you are probably better served buying an AR-15 for $800 if this is your only defensive rifle. Additionally, it is really heavy, and the weight took a toll on the user. We had one Sig 556 that did not have any problems. At this point, for guns I have seen in class the 556 seems to be about 50/50 on whether or not they work well. In the end, it is just a really heavy and expensive AK. Some of the ergonomics are improved, but not enough.

We also had an FN FS2000. This gun is mostly useless. It is bulky and not ergonomic. The peculiar design and controls make gun handling difficult. Some standard procedures need to be abandoned and the operator must adopt some weapon specific techniques. I have seen a few other FS2000s in class. Typically, the operator gives up in frustration by the end of day one and happily switches to an AR platform. Kudos to the operator who ran the gun very well throughout the course.

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-12.jpg

This was another excellent class. Everyone worked hard and learned a lot. Thanks to David, Josh, and especially Nick for keeping me on task and making the course run smoothly. Hopefully next year, we will have the opportunity to run several GDRs at Ravensdale.

Jeff_M
07-11-10, 15:07
http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-1.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-2.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-31.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-4.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-5.jpg

Jeff_M
07-11-10, 15:12
http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-6.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-71.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-9.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-101.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-11.jpg

MookNW
07-11-10, 15:16
Nice writeup Jeff, I look forward to taking this class before the end of the year.
BTW- I noticed people with sidearms, did you cover any transitional shooting?

Jeff_M
07-11-10, 15:17
http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-16.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-18.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-19.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-21.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-22.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-23.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-24.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-25.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-261.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-27.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-28.jpg

Jeff_M
07-11-10, 15:26
MookNW,

Yes transitions are part of the course.

Thanks,
Jeff

Jeff_M
07-11-10, 15:30
http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-29.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-30.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-311.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-32.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-33.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-34.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-35.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-36.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-37.jpg

Jeff_M
07-11-10, 15:35
http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-38.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-39.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-40.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-41.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-42.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-43.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-44.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-45.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-461.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-471.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-48.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-491.jpg

http://insightstraining.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/GDR-06262010-Web-50.jpg

John Frazer
07-11-10, 20:23
I've taken this class twice, ten years apart. There have been changes (mostly to compress it into two days, plus the huge developments in equipment, especially optics) but I highly recommend it.

Key words in Jeff's writeup: "not a fantasy camp."

How'd the M1 carbine do? Would be fun to take this some time with Old School (TM) gear. The first time I took it we had a guy in class with an M1A. I think he switched to an AR on the second or third day.

John Frazer
07-11-10, 20:28
P.S. There are plenty of pistol transitions, especially late in day 2, when the drills compress more shooting and movement into less time; even with good ammo management the carbine will sometimes run dry.

Jeff_M
07-11-10, 22:04
The M1 Carbine is a great alternative for a self defense carbine. It is light and easy to handle. For a private citizen, self defense gun it will work great at a fairly affordable price.

This was an instructor's gun and was only used for a short time durning the class.

I would love it if someone show up with an M1 Carbine to run for all two days (probably not for the first timer though).

BrianS
07-12-10, 04:31
We had mostly ARs in the class. All seemed to run well when lubed, even the piston guns (there’s a first).

Hey Jeff,

Do you guys see lots of problematic piston guns in your GDR classes? When I took GDR last year I remember Greg criticizing piston guns, IIRC sort of as a solution looking for a problem, not necessarily as being unreliable, and also possible issues around proprietary parts.

I would find it really interesting if a design change specifically for the purpose of increasing reliability had the opposite effect according to people who see a lot of guns per year.

Jeff_M
07-12-10, 06:44
I concur with Greg. Generally speaking pistons at this point are a novelty and a solution searching for a problem.

If I shot full auto short barreled suppressed guns all the time, then I might feel different. But I don’t, I just shoot full-auto short barreled Colts and I have yet to see any significant issues.

The piston ARs I have seen the most of in class are LMTs. They generally seem to work very well. I have seen a few LWRCs. Some worked and a couple did not. I have had a Barrett and a CMMG and neither worked. Don’t bother asking why, I neither had the time nor inclination to investigate. All the gas guns seem to work just fine.

If a piston gun is a requirement for you then, I would not buy a re-engineered gas gun (that would be aby AR-15 piston). Buy something originally designed around a piston system like the SCAR.

Bottom line, if you want a cost effective reliable rifle then get a Colt 6920 or something similar. Everything else is still trying to play catch up. When it comes to a practical fighting rifle, I say let someone else be the guinea pig.

andy t
07-12-10, 07:45
Jeff,

As a former FS2000 owner I agree that it has unique controls. I am curious if you base the "bulky and not ergomic" comments of first hand use or observing someone?
In my opinion, with some training FS2000 can be run just as well as an AR and it has some benefits ergonomic wise in some circumstances. The problem is most people that buy it are those that wanted something "space looking" - in the words of one gentleman I took a class with - and don't invest any time in learning the controls and the manual of arms.
Was the instructor familiar with the design to offer some help to the guy running it, if necessary?


http://www.insightstraining.com/blog/
We also had an FN FS2000. This gun is mostly useless. It is bulky and not ergonomic. The peculiar design and controls make gun handling difficult. Some standard procedures need to be abandoned and the operator must adopt some weapon specific techniques. I have seen a few other FS2000s in class. Typically, the operator gives up in frustration by the end of day one and happily switches to an AR platform. Kudos to the operator who ran the gun very well throughout the course.

GlockWRX
07-12-10, 14:35
This was my first time training with Insights even though I am local to them. My only regret is that I didn't do it sooner.

This was a great class. Excellent curriculum and top notch instructors. Jeff provided a lot of instruction time both in the class and on the range. Although the round count is lower than some other carbine courses, you learn from every primer strike. I actually found the class room instruction fascinating and enlightening. This gave me an excellent foundation for future classes.

Nick was especially helpful to me because he showed some different ways for a southpaw to run the AR. I'd never thought of or seen a couple of his techniques, but they are pretty clever.

Jeff also uses a target he designed that makes sighting in an AR a snap. I'm hoping he will make a separate blog post or thread that will explain it and a provide a link to it. It's really slick.

My LWRC ran fine for the class, except my ejection port cover broke. Jeff hardly teased me at all. :p

Other tips from the class:
Bring sunscreen. Us pasty white guys paid for our oversight on that one.
Bring knee and probably elbow pads. While the class didn't spend an inordinate amount of time on the ground, this particular range at Ravensdale used to host trap, so there are broken pigeons on certain areas of the range, which can dig into your sharp parts.
Bring gloves. The shooter to my left tore up his hand pretty good during some of the drills. I loaned him a pair of my gloves that seemed to help. Doing a drill a couple of times probably won't hurt, but after several hours of shooting you find sharp spots on your rifle you didn't think existed.
Jeff's right, bring ammo. Lots of ammo. I ran out just before we quit and fortunately borrowed a couple of mags worth from a generous student (Thanks!). I felt stupid because I had about 1500 rounds sitting on the shelf at home.
Bring silverware for your lunch. I won't mention what some guys went through to eat on the second day. What happens at the range, stays at the range.:eek:

Jeff_M
07-12-10, 16:51
Andy_t,

I have shot the FS2000 on a few occasions. My experience is limited, but I don’t desire to change that. The thing I dislike about the ergonomics is mainly how low it forces the user’s support hand. This was worse on the gun in this last class because it was the railed version.

I agree that the FS2000 can be ran well, and the user in class did an admirable job. However, one must change their rifle TTPs for the gun. For example the bolt does not lock to the rear on the last round. This changes stoppage reduction and reload techniques. It is not the end of the world and if I was issued an FS2000 I would make it work. However, I am not issued one and I don’t see a compelling reason to adopt this platform over a more conventional weapons system such as the AR-15 for my primary fighting carbine.

I think it is great that companies like FN try new ideas and are building different guns. Just like I think the current craze for piston guns is great. That being said, I have no interest in being a guinea pig. Once we have 5 or 10 years and tens of millions if not hundreds of millions of rounds down range proving the superiority of a weapon system then maybe I will switch.

GlockWRX,
You did great in the course. It was a pleasure to train with you again. Hopefully you can make it to Intermediate Rifle sometime.

And I will be sure to add silverware to the required equipment list ;)

Thanks,
Jeff

mk23
07-14-10, 14:00
So Jeff,

When are you guys putting on an Advanced Carbine Course?

And yeah, my FDE Scar runs perfect day in/day out.

I have probably put another 8k though mine since last summer, when we took Ken Hackathorn course in Chehalis...

Angel

Jeff_M
07-14-10, 18:56
Angel,

Good to hear from you. Glad to hear the SCAR is still running strong. Of all the new guns, I think the SCAR has the most promise. I have yet to see one with any problem.

We have Intermediate Rifle at the end of the month. But it is now full. If we get enough interest, we might be able to do a second course in September. If not, we will wait until next summer.

Greg and I have been discussing doing an Intensive Rifle Skills course. It would be the counterpart to our Intensive Handgun Skills course. If you have take IHS, then you know that it is excellent course where we go into excruciating detail regarding technique. This really is no other course like IHS.

If you want to learn to run your carbine fast and increase accuracy then IRS will be the course. If you want to challenge yourself with challenging complex drills that will make you think and shoot at distance then IDR is the course.

Thanks,
Jeff

mk23
07-14-10, 19:08
I would be definitely interested in an IRS course.

I saw Greg mentioned it on the Yahoo group, but I never did see any follow up messages about it.

I might have to sign up fir the IDR too, one of these days. :)