View Full Version : Pig-tail gas tube?
4thPointOfContact
09-14-11, 18:11
Am about to embark on a 10.5 inch SBR build and came across one at a gun show. So are they - -
Just another whiz-bang doodad that does nothing useful or,
solves a problem that I didn't know I had?
Robb Jensen
09-14-11, 18:34
Save your money.
Army Chief
09-14-11, 18:49
Rather than offer a technical opinion, let me just say this: Robb has forgotten more about the AR-15 than 98% of our membership -- myself included -- will ever know. I think you have your answer. =]
AC
Curious to know why exactly they don't offer any sort of improvement. Not that I don't believe that they don't work, just curious to know the science behind it.
Is it a "if it ain't broke don't fix it" sort of thing, or does it actually hinder performance in some way?
Megalomaniac
09-14-11, 21:14
As far as I understand it the pigtail tubes would do nothing, a longer length gas system works via the fact that further from the chamber = less port pressure, a pigtail tube is just making the same port pressure travel a longer distance, instead of bleeding pressure off from a lower pressure spot.
As far as I understand it the pigtail tubes would do nothing, a longer length gas system works via the fact that further from the chamber = less port pressure, a pigtail tube is just making the same port pressure travel a longer distance, instead of bleeding pressure off from a lower pressure spot.
Exactly. No change in port pressure. And probably zero or negligible improvment from the additional tube length.
Heavy Metal
09-15-11, 09:14
The PRI Fatboy is a better execution of this concept. The problem with the Pigtail is it has problems with the coil expanding when hot and affecting function.
4thPointOfContact
09-15-11, 09:56
I had never seen a serious build using one, so I was pretty sure. Thanks for the confirmation. :jester:
Indeed. Since volume = piR^2 x L, increasing the radius of the tube increases the volume by a factor of 4, much more effective than lengthening it.
The problem is too much gas. The pigtail tubes attack the symptoms, not the root cause.
The PRI Fatboy is a better execution of this concept. The problem with the Pigtail is it has problems with the coil expanding when hot and affecting function.
Years ago, they were one of those "gotta have" things for your AR. Now, they are one of those "Holy crap, I can't believe I bought one of those" things. Pass on it.
So does the PRI tube offer much for a carbine gas system then? How about on the SBR's as well?
Robb Jensen
09-16-11, 07:01
So does the PRI tube offer much for a carbine gas system then? How about on the SBR's as well?
It works okay on VERY overgassed 14.5-16" CAR gas guns. I'm talking barrels with gas ports like .090" and larger. Even then you would be far better served with a new barrel with the correct sized port of .0625"
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2024 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.