Originally Posted by
ramairthree
There used to be a five event PT test before my time.
I entered during the 3 event PT test.
Shortly after, they made it much harder for a young guy like I was then to max it.
Then as I got older, the next update was to make it easier for a young guy to pass it but harder for an older guy to do well on it.
All three versions had ridiculously easy run times for women compared to men.
For my last ten years or so in, if I had been king for a day, I would have made a one event PT test.
Put on a 40 pound ruck. Go four miles. If it took over an hour you failed. If you did it in under an hour you passed. Under 40 minutes you were a stud. Under 32 minutes you were a super stud.
The emotional investment to a two mile run exhibiting prowess is fuktarded. It is not a pure speed or explosive strength measure. It is not an endurance measure. It measures nothing about moving in combat equipment. Having two different standards with wildy different standards was even more fuktarded.
There would be two additional events that qualified you to any MOS or position that qualified you for combat arms, leaving the wire, etc.
Climb a 20 for rope. Arms only or using feet, whatever. Just climb it. Regardless of size or strength this exhibits the ability to climb out of a rolled over Pandur, Stryker, aircraft, etc. The ability to climb a ladder and get on a roof, climb over a wall, etc.
Pick up or drag a 180# mannequin 100m in under a minute.
Period. Done deal.
I have seen 130 pounders crush monsters in pushups, same with in real world events despite their ten minute two miler ranking them likes gods in comparison to the monster’s 12 minute or 14 minute two miler.
I have seen an endless parade of women that max their PT test, run triathlons, and “be really good at CrossFit” with monk like fitness dedicated lifestyles who are in the top percentiles of their age and size struggle to hang with totally average guys their age and size that dip, smoke, binge drink on the weekend, and eat like trailer trash, and struggle worse and worse as the days go on.
What is so hard about blocking off a four mile route, putting a scale at the start, having a stop watch, showing up in a uniform with a ruck, and scheduling an hour for a one event test?