It works fine on the 553, but I replaced mine anyway. Call me superficial but the aluminum lower just doesn’t look right.Quote:
Originally Posted by patriot_man
Printable View
It works fine on the 553, but I replaced mine anyway. Call me superficial but the aluminum lower just doesn’t look right.Quote:
Originally Posted by patriot_man
I agree. The Swiss aluminum lower is fine on the 553 and 751, but the combination of a diopter sight 551 upper and aluminum lower has an anachronistic look to it. Analogous to putting a gray Colt M16A1 upper on a current generation M4 lower.Quote:
Originally Posted by freeride1
The aluminum lower looks too American. Yes, if you put the US aluminum lower next to a Swiss aluminum one, you can see the difference. But I'm so used to the look of the steel lowers, the Swiss aluminum one just screams, "Exeter" in my mind.
Y’all are nitpicking. Just be happy you can buy anything at all. We got all but nothing from the time in between from CCF (Larry G), to Armati. That is a long time. You can buy a 553 almost any way you like - gray steel lower and diopters.
False, you could get the crappy Exeter Sig 556, with the crappy aluminum lower.Quote:
Originally Posted by ralfabco
Which is why I bought a steel lower for my Armati 553.
Don’t get me wrong, I’m glad we have Swiss 55x. We can thank CO Gun Sales/Armati for breaking open the floodgates on imports and for Midwest Distributors (and Michaels Machines) for getting LE trade-in 552 and 551 on the commercial market. Without them we would all still be lamenting the lack of Swiss guns.Quote:
Originally Posted by ralfabco
But, I wish JDI would have done gray and black complete 551s with steel lowers and more discrete import markings. JDI has done a real service in continuing the import of Swiss 55x. That one can order a 553 with their choice of short or long barrel, gray or black finish, steel or aluminum lower, green or black furniture, diopter or pic rail upper - that is truly awesome.
Quote:
Originally Posted by freeride1
Ha. Well said.
What about the 55x design makes it so that the upper has to be steel instead of machined aluminum? Hypothetically speaking, if someone wanted to make a next gen rifle based on the 55x design, would it be possible to make it entirely aluminum (for weight saving, as that seems to be all the rage these days)?
My main reason for asking is pure curiosity, as I've always be interested in the SG55x series, and I'm just trying to learn a bit more about their engineering.
Sure it’s possible.Quote:
Originally Posted by BoringGuy45
The upper is stamped. It wouldn't be possible to keep it strong enough with the same inside and outside dimensions if it was made out of aluminum.Quote:
Originally Posted by BoringGuy45
This is correct. You would end up with a different gun.Quote:
Originally Posted by Bret