Originally Posted by
Flashman
As one who has shot and competed with revolvers for years please consider these cautionary notes.
1. Buying an older used handgun that is not longer manufactured or supported by the manufacturer can be problematic. Older Smith revolvers are no longer supported by S&W. However, there are millions of older Smiths and aftermarket internal parts which makes it less risky. Ruger no long supports the Security Six line so no new parts are available.
2. Fixed sighted revolvers can be problematic in terms of point of aim vs point of impact depending on the load, etc.
3. Revolvers do break and sometimes exhibit wear issues.
For those experienced with revolvers who buy used revolvers, they know the ups and downs, how to regulate sights, etc. However, for neophytes like myself 30 years ago, it was an expensive, long, frustrating but ultimately rewarding journey.
For me, a Ruger GP or SP would be the top choice: No external locks, ability to completely disassemble and clean the revolver without special tools, knowledge, etc., and Ruger support. If it doesn't shoot to POA, then they will regulate the sights (within reason). Ruger warranty is like long term maintenance policy: e.g., frame stretches after thousands of rounds--they either adjust/shim the cylinder or replace the gun. Smith also has a great warranty and they pay the shipping both ways!