I am taking a serious look at the Leupold vx-Hog, looks good for the price
Printable View
Now that you mention Leupold, I'm wondering if the VX-1 Shotgun/muzzleloader 1-4X20mm might be the way to go. I like the Turkey Plex reticule.
Burris has a Fullfield Tac 30 for about $299 at most places. It is the same scope internally as the MTAC but it has the older push button illumination and the older style body and turret caps.
http://www.burrisoptics.com/ff30tactical1.html
I'm a red dot guy myself, but the Vortex has got me thinking of switching one of my ARs to a 1-4. I own a Vortex 3X magnifier and the glass is great, a lot better than I was expecting. I heard they were making the Viper PST in 1-6 also.
http://i1169.photobucket.com/albums/...g?t=1346642192
I think I am going Weaver Classic Extreme 1.5x4.5-24 or Leupold VX-Hog. What the Weaver's got going for it is the illuminated recticle and Natchez has them within the wife's price range.
I vote for the Burris MTAC 1-4x.
For background, I've had the Burris FF TAC30 1-4x for a while and have been mostly happy with it, except the control over illumination. The MTAC fixes that with a much more useful dial. I've looked through the MTAC 1-4x at a recent match and it was definitely at least as good as the TAC30 - basically the same optics but with better controls, as far as I can tell.
I also have an MTAC 1.5-6x40 so I'm quite familiar with the controls.
I briefly owned the Nikon M-223 1-4x20 and did not like it. I thought the glass wasn't very good, especially compared to the TAC30. I sold it after using it very briefly.