Well I hope someone buys that stove I linked above. I got mine today and it's an older military surplus model. It had and NSN on it and everything but said PEAK1 by Coleman.
it had never been used or even fueled up!! it's a helluva deal for $28 shipped.
all the parts were there and the instructions. I topped it off and decided to pull out the other stoves for a head to head test.
I boiled 1 liter of water on high after each stove had warmed up. I'm at 5000ft and the temperature was 51degrees. the water was cold water right out of the hose probably in the 40-50 degree range. here's what happened:
Primus #71 military stove. I got this at a gunshow for $20 and it's an old white gas/coleman fuel generator no-pump style. the thing just rocks. it came as a complete kit with pot, top, handle, stove, burner assembly and adjustment tool. to prime it you have to fill up a little resevoir on the tank with fuel and close the valve then set it on fire. it's freaky but it heats up the shaft and vaporizes the fuel and then is self generating from there on out. it took 7:30 to boil the water
Primus MFS multifuel stove. looks like the new primus omnifuel or the MSR whisperlite international. I used Isobutane compressed gas canister. it took 8:15 to boil
the Peak1 / Exponent Coleman got topped off with white gas/coleman fuel and pumped up pretty good after a warmup then let er rip. it took 8:45 to boil
all these stoves were really close together in performance. I wouldnt hesitate to grab any of them but the white gas stoves both have a neat little self contained package that is hard to beat for functional usage. the compressed gas is easier and faster to make go, and that might give it a slight advantage but I wouldnt say any of them have a decided advantage.
bang for the buck, the $20 gunshow special is a real winner, and the Exponent/PEAK1 is right there next to it. The primus MFS/omnifuel is SO flexible as it can use isobutane, Gasoline, White gas, Kerosene, Diesel and jet fuel with the provided fuel tank and pump.
As a side note, I have been pouring out of the same can of coleman fuel since 1995 and it still works just fine. I have no idea what the shelf life is supposed to be but keeping it around seems like a good idea. I've always had better luck with it than Unleaded or diesel.
Last edited by Jack-O; 05-18-12 at 22:14.
My capacity for self deception is exceeded only by yours.
Bookmarks