XDs, HK P2000sk or glock 27 which is best and why?

**Deltaspeed93** · 07-26-12, 17:50

I almost picked up an XDs today on impulse....I have been saving for a .40 HK P2000 sk. I also havehad my eye on the G27.
I want this gun to be one I can take out and just have fun with not just a man stopper, Thats why I wanted the HK originally. I know it's heavier and fatter than the glock. but I also don't like the idea of the single stack XDs 6 rounds of .45

Price aside, What would you guys pick and why?...I know 2 are .40 and 1 is .45 so it's not a really fair to compare them but they are roughly the same size.

**wahoo95** · 07-26-12, 18:07

Not a decision we can make for you. I'd pick the one that "I" shoot best and carry best. Pretty sure those factors will be different for different people so expect lots of subjective answers

Sent from my DROIDX using Tapatalk 2

**.45's and .38's** · 07-26-12, 18:19

The XDS is great but I would like more mag capacity, so I chose the glock 27. I would definately give the glock a good feel over & make sure it points right for you. a lot of people find the grip angle to naturally point the gun upwards when aiming it. I find the glock 17 points high when I aim but the smaller sub compacts point a bit more natural to me, like a XD. Glock 27 has a nice capacity, 40 ammo is priced well & is a great round.....number one reason I would take the glock over the other 2, is.....Lone wolf.....conversion barrel to 9mm. I have owned many glocks & many conversion barrels & I think they are a fantastic mix. takes about 30 seconds to swap barrels. just need a 9mm magazine & your good to go

40 for carry & cheap 9mm to plink with

I would pick the gun that fits my hand best, something that I can easily hit all the controls on the weapon without changing my grip angle. If a range has the guns for rent, that would be even better

**Greg Bell** · 07-26-12, 20:10

P2000SK. It will be the most problem free in my opinion.

**C4IGrant** · 07-26-12, 20:20

Unless you are getting .40 ammo for FREE, I have no idea why you would choose this caliber over 9mm.

Of those choices, I would go with the HK.

C4

**zacii** · 07-26-12, 20:29

I've never shot an HK, but I do like the lower bore axis of the Glock over the XD, personally.

Sent from my Galaxy S2

**.45fmjoe** · 07-26-12, 23:17

Originally Posted by Greg Bell

P2000SK. It will be the most problem free in my opinion.

I agree, my service weapon is a P2000 and it's been a phenomenal pistol. I've NEVER had a malfunction in the year and ~4,000 rounds I have through it. I have complete confidence it will serve me well until it's eventually replaced.

**Hogsgunwild** · 07-26-12, 23:22

I easily prefer the H&K but is there a reason the M&P compact is not included here? I think it is a more updated design than all of the others that you are looking at. The trigger and ergonomics alone make it worth considering for me.