
Originally Posted by
SPQR476
We have an initiative that is doing some continuing side x side testing for release, and we'll probably start showing more of what we've done already. We've also long had a policy of not releasing our test data when it refers to others in the marketplace just due to a perception of bias, but we may re-evaluate that position at some point to set the record straight with video and other evidence, if necessary. We do our testing with large enough sample sizes and with strict control measures that anyone is welcome to replicate. Dust boxes, multi-axis drops on the same mag, multi-axis full weapon drops on the same mag, floorplate endurance, mag well ripout, -60 to 180, tac-reload repetition, magazine monopod firing, etc., with FEEDING and FUNCTIONING testing on the backside. We do some testing that we won't release because it's secret sauce that helps us maintain QC that is difficult to attain, but most will likely be released.
The expectations of modern magazine performance are pretty amazing, but it's difficult to see the true differences without LARGE samples. If you fire 2,000 rounds through 6 magazines in a week-long, mega training class, and you have 2 stoppages the entire time...was it ammo? Was the gun dry? Was it the mag? Feed ramp sharp? We tend to make excuses for our gear when running it hard. In that context, if it was 2, or even one magazine-related failures in 2k rounds...heads would roll, here, or at least we certainly would consider that an abysmal failure and launch an investigation as to why.
The USGI is something of a nameless, faceless standard that we don't mind showing the weaknesses of, but manufacturer DEFINITELY matters. Coming from Brownells, I'm very familiar with the aluminum magazine, what it takes to make one, what it's good at, and what it's not, and I don't feel uncomfortable with good aluminum mags with our follower. I'm just more likely to scrap an aluminum and replace it if there's any question whatsoever about impacts to the feed lips, body sides, etc., and I clean them. I treat PMAGs like I treat Glocks. Unkindly.
Bookmarks