That's a funny joke. I like it.
Yet, the reputation the French have as frog-eating surrender monkeys is of chiefly post WWI origin. For most of the 19th century and even prior, Germans were thought of as poets and thinkers, whereas French were seen as all things martial. Most military manuals were written in French; the greatest soldier of the age, Napoleon, led the French. At the time of the American Civil War, to study German military thought was thought laughable, and almost all American officers, who studied any manuals or military thought at all, studied the French. It was the French that most of Europe was afraid of and most Europeans made alliances against.
Napoleon and his legacy was what defined most military thought in the 19th century: Jomini, and even Clausewitz, developed their thought while studying Napoleon and the Napoleonic Wars. It was not until the Prussians united Germany and began whipping up on the French in the Franco-Prussian War, 1870-71, under a genius named Moltke, that this began to change.
However, even in WWI, at least in 1914-1916, the French soldiers were some of the bravest and most gung-ho of any soldiers in history. To see what I mean, look up the theories of Ardant du Picq; he personified the same kind of absolute fearless, charge-into-battle, gut-eating detrmination that the Japanese did in the Russo-Japanese War, and in the Pacific.



Reply With Quote
Bookmarks