I think the Gen 1's "look" more similar to an ACOG, which is what you're wanting, but the reason I would get a Gen 1 is because they are not as bad to come with canted reticles. I may be wrong, I've never owned one, but from all the reviews I have read online, I read more Gen II's having canted reticles, than Gen I's. That granted, the Gen II's updates and improvements may more than make up for that risk.
Even the best can make a mistake, even Leupold is kicking out quite a few Mark 4's with canted reticles LOL... only difference is, Leupold will fix it! LOL
Buy whichever one you can get the best deal on, and have fun with it!
EDIT: Here's a pic of my M4 w/ ACOG, this is bad pic, but at a distance, people who don't know any better won't be able to tell the difference LOL.
EDIT: Read this: Torture test Trophy MP https://www.m4carbine.net/showthread.php?t=18751
"A government big enough to give you what you want, is strong enough to take what you have." -T. Jefferson
Bookmarks