I would probably place the Ruger American Pistol in this category. I never seem to hear anything about it these days (either pro or con).
Beretta PX4 and APX. The older 92 series seems to generate more buzz, for whatever reason.
Walther Creed. Just seemed to flop right off the bat. The previous PPX didn't seem to do much better. Shame , too, because my PPX is reliable and accurate.
Any Steyr handgun. Not sure why.
Any other candidates?
Bookmarks