
Originally Posted by
Averageman
Having watched all that and having read the entire thread, What is the preferred method for dealing with this?
This is my opinion and my opinion only, worth every bit you paid for it.
As the video starts, the officer who made the stop is standing, back to the offender, talking to the Sergeant. The Sergeant, probably, reacting more to how the other officer approached and positioned, seems to be looking into the strobes, perhaps he could see over them since it appears his bodycam is on his chest. In any event, the officer should have positioned himself so he could watch the vehicle HE had apparently stopped, and let the Sergeant position himself appropriately.

Originally Posted by
Averageman
Talking him out didn't work.
Like FF said, they let it go on to long. I'm a nice guy, I believe verbal judo works on some folks, but, there are cues when it isn't and the officer went past those cues, circled back around, and then went past them again. Words you don't say - 'I'm going to tell you one last time' everytime you say that and don't take action, you empower the subject you are dealing with to further resist. Counting down, again, when you get to zero and don't do anything.....

Originally Posted by
Averageman
Tazing him didn't work.tying to drag him out didn't work.
The TASER requires about 12 inches of probe spread, ideally in different well-muscled quadrants of the body to lock someone up. A good window is 7 to 15 feet. I don't know how far the Sergeant was when he deployed, but I'd think shy of seven feet. Additionally, had the tase been effective, the car was between the two officers. Getting him out of the vehicle and controlling to cuff without a disconnect would be problematic.
A better option would have been for the Sergeant to come to the driver's side, and do a probe in driver stun - you fire the taser at close range getting two darts in close together, and then ground the front of the taser into another part of the body at least 12-14 inches away (drive stun) - this locks the guy up, and your other officer can grab him and get him out for control.
The problem in that I was a TASER instructor for over a decade, all that is second nature to me, these guys probably had the original shake-and-bake class, then a minimal re-certification. TASER training should at a minimum be 16 hours, preferably 24. That way you get to do multiple reps of arrest and control drills. Nobody wants to do that (well, some officers might, but how often do you hear of agencies saying 'go beyond the minimum' for defensive tactics training?)
TASER, deployed properly would have worked, but, given the level of TASER training, understandable why it didn't.

Originally Posted by
Averageman
Spraying him with pepper spray didn't work.
Again training. The introduction of OC into the subject's face should be a fvcking surprise. You should not display the OC projector to the suspect, you should not warn 'Comply or I'm going to spray you.' All those things just give the subject time to duck their head, throw there arm up, etc. Which this guy did.
Additionally, many officers are too nice when using OC, they give the subject a little baby spray instead of a continuous 2 to 3 second discharge into the target area.
Once again, a training issue. Many agencies give you OC and after initial training figure 'it's so simple a caveman could do it' and let it go.
Another thing that we need to keep in mind, many officers, even in large jurisdictions, can go for extended periods between handling belligerent folks like this. When incidents like this confront those officers, it may take them a while to get up to speed.
I hope officer who watch the video can learn from it.
God Speed SErgeant, hope the other officer recovers fully.
Patriotism means to stand by the country. It does not mean to stand by the President... - Theodore Roosevelt, Lincoln and Free Speech, Metropolitan Magazine, Volume 47, Number 6, May 1918.
Every Communist must grasp the truth. Political power grows out of the barrel of a gun. Our principle is that the Party commands the gun, and the gun must never be allowed to command the Party Mao Zedong, 6 November, 1938 - speech to the Communist Patry of China's sixth Central Committee
Bookmarks