Originally Posted by
ViniVidivici
Okay now you guys jogged my memory.....Sum of all Fears was a great book......but Ben Asslick was the WORST Jack Ryan in the history of all moviedom. Gary fookin' Coleman woulda been more believable......
Hard to believe that Afleck, who was so good in Argo, was so f'ing bad in Sum of all Fears, but honestly once they made it about neo nazis, I didn't care that they screwed everything else up to.
As far as "black guys", Denzel Washington took an 80s movie called "Man on Fire" and blew the original out of the water. The original was about wealthy Italian families needing bodyguards against the threat of kidnapping. Scott Glenn played Creasy, Joe Pesci played his former partner and buddy and it was slow, dull and nobody saw it.
Denzel Washington and Christopher Walken came along and slam dunked it. Nobody cared that he played a white character in the original.
I get Clancy books are a bit different, if we made Chavez Norwegian it wouldn't work for many of the same reasons. It's because when we read the books, the characters were defined and set in memory and if you stray from that, it becomes a problem. Hell the relative ages of Clarke vs. Ryan in "Sum of all Fears" was a problem.
By the same token if you did the story of Malcom X starring Jackie Chan, it would be a problem. If you do the Bruce Lee story starring Michael Jai White, it would be a problem. And it's not that Michael Jai White doesn't actually have an impressive level of martial arts skills. It's that people care about Bruce Lee, Malcom X and Clancy characters and how they are presented.
Now if you are making Abraham Lincoln Vampire Killer, and you want Lincoln to be portrayed by Jackie Chan or Michael Jai White...go for it. I might even watch that POS if you put Jackie Chan or Michael Jai White in it, they might be able to save that stupid shit.
And that is the part I think Hollywood just doesn't grasp. The problem isn't the black guy being in the movie, the problem is the role. And the problem isn't making sure they don't have too important a role, because I don't think anyone is going to do a better James Greer anytime soon. I will always see James Earl Jones in that role and god help anyone who has to try and fill those shoes in any future production.
If Greer isn't black you are going to throw up the accepted Clancy definitions of the characters but even if he is black, he better be really good and able to step up. Maybe if Denzel is really old and has really filled out he could pull it off. But imagine he's played by an intrepid lesbian like Rooney Mara just to be fashionable, it's going to be a disaster.
I personally want to do the Amelia Earhart story starring Zhang Ziyi because why not?
Then I want to do the Katherine Hepburn story starring Joe Exotic because why not?
Then I want to do the Meryl Streep story starring Margaret Cho because why not?
Then I want to do the Martin Luther King story starring Jack Black because why not?
Then just maybe a few people might start to "get it."
It's hard to be a ACLU hating, philosophically Libertarian, socially liberal, fiscally conservative, scientifically grounded, agnostic, porn admiring gun owner who believes in self determination.
Chuck, we miss ya man.
كافر
Bookmarks