Ok, so I've had the polite discourse with an LE when I was rolling a MP5 on the passenger seat. I was calm and knew how to talk to cops without freaking them out and he was an experienced officer who quickly understood I wasn't actually a threat.
I'm glad you know what I'm talking about but at the same time if you drew on me, I'm going to remain calm and collected but still consider it very impolite and it will be taken up at a later time. I've been through that twice and while nobody got shot on one occasion I did make an issue out of it later, because the guy was really, really wrong about a few things and needed to know.
So obviously we don't want to do 10 pages and I bolded the most important part of your statement. I completely agree with "cover your bases" and other due diligence but sometimes you need to work without a net because somebody is just retarded but they aren't being a legit threat (or you are 90% positive they aren't a legit threat).
I think the three of us are mostly on the same page but just looking at it from different sides. While not directed to you, lots of cops find fault with the actions of some LEO who just got shot on YT as a way to self reinforce "can't happen to me, he made a mistake, I won't do that" and while that validation is important and helps keep you on your toes I still stop shot of "Jarrott did something wrong" because I personally believe he was set up in a bad place without sufficient information by reprehensible assholes who didn't want to do their own job.
I think you guys both keyed in on a point where Jarrott realized "something's wrong" but it was too late and he didn't have time to process to "this guy is going to try and kill me right now" before it actually started happening.
And I hope I'm not coming across too hard like I'm debating you, this one just really pissed me off. The first time I saw it, I sorta had a sick feeling for a couple minutes and that's rare these days. Last time I got that from a video was probably the Daniel Pearl video and if you don't know what it is already don't go looking for it.
It's hard to be a ACLU hating, philosophically Libertarian, socially liberal, fiscally conservative, scientifically grounded, agnostic, porn admiring gun owner who believes in self determination.
Chuck, we miss ya man.
كافر
Question for the law enforcement here: I know that DHS didn’t give this poor trooper enough intel, but when DHS asks you to initiate a stop, wouldn’t that set off alarm bells? As in, don’t treat this stop casually in any way, shape, or form? I don’t think the trooper did treat it casually, but neither did he seem to be trying to control the situation. Was he trying to get the driver to drop his guard?
And what was the reason for trying to get him out of the car? Or was that part of the plan from DHS.
Sent from 80ms in the future
I say this not trying to sound douchey but I would rather get complained on rather than be paralyzed with a colostomy or dead. I’m at a point in life where complaints don’t register with me (not that I get complained on really).
Without veering into “what if” territory, you can kinda suss out the difference between someone just hauling a gun versus someone up to no good.
And Again without my words being used as a template for any What If: Choose Your Own Adventure mental extrapolation, I say this:
If I am not 100% on someone armed, I would rather ask them out of the vehicle where I am at the advantage and can see everything with a positive reaction gap. At the first sign of non-compliance then I am egressing while drawn or I am going to close and shove a gun in his face. A legitimate honest person will understand. A dishonest person realizes he is losing his advantage and will show his cards.
It’s Art and Science. There’s not always a concrete answer. Only a broadly worded statute, perhaps case law, and a policy.
Side of the road is no place to argue or be Rosa Parks.
That said, I’ve let people be actively holstered up with whatever guns in their vehicle because you can tell they were shooting or hunting or whatever dumb shit they were doing.
If I see or smell weed or liquor or a beaten up woman or child or somebody giving me the “oh shit oh shit” stare; then I’m probably not going to be so liberal about it.
Same if a person is sizing me up. That’s absolutely a fast track to gun in face time. If I see someone wanting to try their cowboy hand or staring at my gun then I will gladly give them a closer look.
The Cartel guy was obviously sizing this trooper up and the trooper knew it but still went along like it was Leroy with a Dimebag.
None of you know just how many police officers seriously don’t believe someone will actually kill them. The bodycam on his corpse is giving you a Body eye view of what it’s like to be dead. You’re just waste at that point.
I won’t lie and say my life cosmically matters. It doesn’t and most likely I’m going to Hell. But it is my life and there is a principle at play here so you’re gonna have to work for it if you wanna kill me
And I wouldn't want you to get killed or crippled either. I think we both have a "don't show me yours and I won't show you mine" understanding.
Like I said, been through it twice. Once really bothered me because it was all wrong, the other didn't bother me because I quickly got on the same page and we moved passed.
Btw, last time I starred at a cops gun was because she was rolling a really old Beretta with wooden grips and I hadn't seen that in a long time. She probably thought I was checking out her ass. Normally it's just a quick glance "Ugh, Glock...man you need to step up to something better." Anyone still rolling 1911s get's a "nice sidearm" comment.
It's hard to be a ACLU hating, philosophically Libertarian, socially liberal, fiscally conservative, scientifically grounded, agnostic, porn admiring gun owner who believes in self determination.
Chuck, we miss ya man.
كافر
Lets see if his command staff raises a stink about the feds who got him killed.
Lets see if his fellow officers stage a walk out or do anything to try hold the feds responsible.
Lets see if those 2 feds get fired for gross incompetence.
I bet they wont.
After 4 pages you are the only one mentioning trying to hold the feds who served him up responsible. Looks like you are one of the few people who gets it. All the useless outrage "OMG he shot him point blank in the head, OH THE HORROR!!!" isnt going to do anything. All the videos of the cartels chopping people up and melting faces off with a blow torch and people still don't understand that animals are going to do what animals are going to do.
Last edited by vicious_cb; 04-15-21 at 03:15.
I don't like "what ifs" because you can always argue into something that's unwinnable anyway so I'll just say that almost everyone I encounter in the field is armed, usually handguns and often concealed but often with longarms (sometimes more than one) as well and not just during hunting season. I have never gone Defcon 2 simply because I saw a firearm. I'd be lying, tho, if I said it made no matter because the fact is I don't know YOU or your intentions off the get-go.
Most of the time I end up just talking about gun nerd stuff for a minute and then we're all friends.
Also, airsoft gun or not, if it looks like a M4 then that's how it will be seen.
Ummmm HELLO.
Post 16:
Post 18:That DHS had a local officer initiate a stop with no warning of what he was dealing with is so negligent I don't know where to start. Heads need to roll.
It needs to be the main focus in my opinion. Sure as shit the current administration is gonna focus on the firearm used, but this is worse than Fast and Furious (where ATF lost track of firearms deliberately provided to drug cartels, one of which was used to murder a border patrol officer), in this case it very much seems that DHS blindly walked this officer into his own death and could have orchestrated events in such a way where they directly participated in the traffic stop / first contact and provided direct support but chose not to.
This might be the worst thing I have ever seen.
Your comment about state and local LE enforcing federal law notwithstanding, I think the real take away is state and local LE can no longer simply trust federal law enforcement for anything. Everyone involved in this operation from the top down to the guys who were only "minutes away" need to be investigated, fired and sentenced.
It's hard to be a ACLU hating, philosophically Libertarian, socially liberal, fiscally conservative, scientifically grounded, agnostic, porn admiring gun owner who believes in self determination.
Chuck, we miss ya man.
كافر
Bookmarks