Two new builds, opinions please.

[camoman]

The black GI is a stealth arms, alloy, bobtail complete kit.

The OD is a Stealth arms alloy frame, Remsport commander slide, barrel, EGW hard sear, Houge grip, Truglow TFO sights, and Klonimus bits.

What do you people think?

[Pappabear]

Top black one, don't know squat about either one. Just don't like the grips on the tan one.

PB

[HKGuns]

I think the black one looks too "black" and would look sharp with some nice Rosewood stocks

.

[Steve_in_Allentown]

Looks are only surface deep. In my book 100% functioning is first and foremost. If it'll feed, fire, extract, and eject everything out of any magazine, I'm a happy camper. If it hiccups in any way, I'm not. I don't care if it's painted orange with purple polka dots.

[camoman]

I think the black one looks too "black" and would look sharp with some nice Rosewood stocks

.

That could be an option.
Those are the grips that came with the kit.
Unfortunately, the kit was two grip screws short. I’m not really worried about it. I did send S/A an email about the missing screws, haven’t heard back yet. Worst case scenario, I have to order grip screws.
The kit was so nice, I’m not gonna make a stink about it….besides, it’s companies the S/A who’ve been busting their asses, trying to keep up with demand for a pristine, American made product.

The OD Commander, I thought was too much OD, but it’s growing on me.

[camoman]

Looks are only surface deep. In my book 100% functioning is first and foremost. If it'll feed, fire, extract, and eject everything out of any magazine, I'm a happy camper. If it hiccups in any way, I'm not. I don't care if it's painted orange with purple polka dots.

I had a few hiccups with the Commander, but after I learned how to properly fit the extractor…the hiccups went away.
The GI has only had 16 rounds through it. So far it’s perfect.