I currently have a Gen 2 G19 and Gen 3 G17. Generally, the 17 (w/light) is my HD/travel pistol and my G19 is my carry pistol.

Does the G17 have any advantage over the G34 other than being .8" shorter and an ounce lighter? I feel the 17 and 19 are so close together that having both does not make a lot of sense, but I like having the light on a longer pistol. I think I would enjoy the 34 at the range.

If I replace it, the G17 will be passed to one of my sons. Ironically, my current G17 is a replacement for the G17 I gave to another son.

Thanks

Andy