Seller's Remorse

[bundoc]

How many of you have sold a gun and had seller's remorse?

I am trying to stick to one caliber, 9mm, and saw a Glock 17 in a local shop for $479. They also have Glock 19s for $529. I originally went into the store just to get a price for my used CPO 226 in 357 Sig when I came across the Glock.

I have only owned Sig pistols and have been curious about polymer guns. The gentleman behind the counter offered me $450 for it; fortunately, I only paid $500 for it 3 yrs ago. Would you ask to do an even trade for the Glock? My primary carry piece is a p228 which I love.

The 226 is also my first gun that I bought, but I just do not shoot it like I used to since 9mm ammo is so much cheaper. I would probably end up using the Glock for CCW and understand the 19 would be easier to conceal. I am just leaning towards the 17 if I do go through with the trade because it seems like a great deal. Any input would be appreciated.

[8200rpm]

I wouldn't trade it for the G17 since it's not what you really want. Pay the extra $50 and get the G19.

[BH1]

I'm no Sig expert but $450 for a P226 sounds a bit on the low side from what I've seen, even if .357sig isn't the most in demand caliber.

Here's another idea: if the P228 is what you really like have you considered looking to trade for either a P226 in 9mm or another P228 rather than something completely different?

[mattjmcd]

I wouldn't trade it for the G17 since it's not what you really want. Pay the extra $50 and get the G19.

Concur.

It's just not enough of a gap too justify a compromise, IMO. Get the G19. (assuming I am reading you correctly...)

[bundoc]

I was looking around on gunbroker for either another 228 or 226 in 9mm, but they have been out of my price range. Buying the 19 makes a lot more sense for $50 more. Thanks for the suggestions.

[wargasm]

I bought a SIG P228 in 9mm from Galyan's Sporting Good's when they were converting over to Dick's. Got it for $450. Sold it for $350 when I got into a financial pinch, or so I thought. I vowed never to make that mistake again!

[LittleRedToyota]

i'm not completely up to speed on typical G19 pricing, but for a G17, at least, i would personally shop around and find a used one for $400 or less.

they aren't that hard to find (if you don't have to find it this very moment) for that price. police trade-ins are great for that.

ymmv, of course, but this has worked well for me on multiple occassions.

[NoBody]

Deleted.

[OPPFOR]

I hate it when this topic is brought up. It reminds me of a couple of handguns I wish I had not parted with. Keep it if you think you will miss it for any reason.

[mtk]

Think of your gun safe as the Hotel California....