This is a great topic.
Over the years of building and shooting 1911s, I have found opinions vary widely, this is totally a matter of personal preference
I have one customer who is a high speed SWAT guy, he insists on a totally agressive pistol- sharp 20LPI front and back, and sharp checkered composite grips, and 30lpi checkered bottom of trigger guard. Another customer, who is a climber who consults and trains various high speed groups, prefers a totally smooth gun- smooth front and backstraps, very mildly textured grips. I would have thought he would prefer a lot of traction. Ironically, most of my amphibious customers have specified smooth guns and are happy with them.
My personal preference is this:
I want some traction on my pistol even if it's just worn in skate tape.
20LPI is way too sharp and aggressive for me- it's downright painful and it eats cover garments.
Pointed golfballs I find to be a lot like 20lpi - too agressive for me, though like checkering they can be toned down..
Snakeskin is great, I like the directional nature of it and the level of "bite" can be fine tuned by changing the angle of the scales. It's pretty agressive to clothing, though.
I like the feel of 30lpi front and back.
Scallops and the wide spaced golf ball are my favorites to date- they have the best all around combination of traction "grab/release", resistance to damage and ease of cleaning, without taking a toll on cover garments.
Bookmarks