Choosing the Right Weapon Light

**whiterabbit05** · 10-24-09, 03:25

^I was referring more to the X300 vs the TLR1.

**usmcvet** · 10-24-09, 09:28

That makes more sense

. We have both at work. We went to new ALS holsters for our duty guns when we changed from the Sig 226R DAK to the Glock 22. We bought an X300 and received a TLR1 free from Streamlight during the Testing and Evaluation Period. We went with the TLR1 because you can buy Two for One plus about a dozen batteries! They both have their strong points. The TLR1 is easier to activate, IMO, with your finger. The X300 is requires much more pressure to activate for both momentary and constant on. I actually ended up buying the DG switch so I could maintain proper shooting grip while still allowing me to use my light. I’m sure Streamlight has a similar option but I’ve never used one. So with the DG switch we are up to the price of 3 TLR1's

.

The Surefire has a smaller profile and is much quicker to re-holster again IMO. The X300 goes on and off the weapon quicker w/o messing with screws. This is not a huge issue for me because it stays on and only comes off for cleaning. If you had a need to add and remove the light the X300 would save time. I carry my Glock 27 off duty and the G22 stays in her ALS! If you were switching back and forth to a concealment holster w/o light capabilities’ the X300 is quicker.

During our first night fire we learned one of our female officers could not activate her TLR1 because she has very small hands. This of course could be an issue for men with small hands too. SOOOO off came my X300 and coveted DG switch and she was good to go! The sacrifices we make for our People! I found a gently used X300 at my local cop shop and bought it. Another DG switch came my way through a trade for a few boxes of simmunitions! So I used my own money for the X300 about $200 and would do it again. I think it is a better light and it works for me. The TLR1 is also a good light and offers you more money for ammo and batteries! It's all a personal choice.

**Vic303** · 10-25-09, 16:23

I thought Streamlight also made a tapeswitch for the TLR series lights...
They do, for at least the TLR2.

**usmcvet** · 10-25-09, 20:50

You're right looks like it's only $28.00 for the switch and $35.70 for the replacement door! With the light it would be aound $165

Streamlight TLR Remote Battery Door Switch Assembly.

• For TLR-1 and TLR-2 Weaponlights
• Replaces standard battery door/switch
• Retains momentary/lock On function
• Tethered rubber weather cap protects connector
• Remotes feature rotating quick disconnect plug
• O-ring seal

Our Price $35.70 (Retail Price $51.00)

Streamlight TLR Plug-In Remote Switches

These remote switch assemblies are used with the Streamlight TLR-1 and TLR-2 weaplonlights that have been retrofitted with the Battery Door Switch Assembly (above).

The remote tape switch fits most right-angle grips and other aftermarket accessories. The long gun remote switch attaches to rail forend and includes mounting clips. The shotgun coil remote switch allows for expansion of cord with pump action.

• For TLR-1 and TLR-2 Weaponlights
• Use with TLR Battery Door Switch Assembly
• Includes mounting accessories

**goodale** · 11-05-09, 21:33

check out what my man nutnfancy has to say about diffrent lights i have respect for his opinions. he has some flash light reviews check out the streamlight tlr3 and his reviews on fenix lights. high quality and inexpensive. http://www.youtube.com/user/nutnfancy#p/u/6/2l9jAKf5gNY

**ColtM4pilot** · 11-06-09, 07:13

I cant see why anyone would use a regular flashlight like a G2 with a separate mount. Considering the performance of the TLR and X300, I dont get it. These lights are lighter and more compact, plus you can use them on your pistol. I think weight is an important factor for any weapon, especially a carbine.

I have several TLR-1's and couldnt imagine a better light all things considered (durability, performance, price, weight...etc).

Anyway, interested in hearing why some like the added weight and complexity of a flashlight and mount on their rifle?

**usmcvet** · 11-06-09, 10:02

I agree with you. When I set my gun up the weapon lights were not as inexpensive and led was not an option. I would go the weapon light route not and I would seriously consider the Moe Hand Guard or a regular hand guard with a GG&G attachment so I could eliminate the need for a pistol grip and rail. The pistol lights are brighter and have a longer burn time and can save you serious money if you decide to go without a rail and pistol grip on the rail. It's the old KISS principle. I think that is the route I am going to go with my next gun, just waiting for a few ne receivers from Grant at G&R. One will get a Troy rail one will a Moe and a TLR1.

**Outlander Systems** · 11-06-09, 12:30

The X300 has a runtime of 2.4 hours. The G2LED has a runtime of 3 hours, so they're comparable in performance.

I personally tried the X300, and didn't have enough faith in the mount to leave it on my long-gun. Someone else may find that it may work for their needs, but I see any peripheral hanging off the side of my smokewagon as a fulcrum. The strength of the mount is relative to the amount of force required to inadvertently snap the peripheral off of the rail . The X300, from my point of view, didn't offer enough in the way of support strength to justify having on a long gun. Mounting it in front of the FSB, like the DD rails allow, would create less of an obtrusion, thusly making it more secure.

Since I don't have the DD rail that extends past the FSB, my options are side mounting only.

Other people's needs may differ, and I'm just slinging in my perspective.

**s85sss** · 11-07-09, 12:48

X200a - one of the best ever owned. simple and compact, but only last 60 minutes...
TLR 2 - arrived yesterday, i think is much overated and overpriced, did not get much enthusiasm for that really.
Surefire M961 and Tangodown VG - great setup. the light is solid as a rock and fits perfectly the TD spacer for the remote. i used the light with the Surefire L60 lamp, and it worked with the remote without any problem.
Surefire G2 and 6P - nice handhelds, nothing more. Getting a clicky tailcaps could be a little expensive.
Right now i really would like to find a X200B...price are going to be low, since it's been a while since its debut...

hope it helped