When my department first allowed 1911's we probably had about 30 or so Kimbers fielded (mostly TLE II's and TLE/RL II's). Of those guns at least half had problems that rendered the guns inoperable. I am also aware of several neighboring departments that have had the same issues. Luckily these problems occurred in a training environment rather than on the street.
I carry a Springfield Professional at work (until I get my Jardine Colt) and I am of the opinion that the Pro and like pistols are the MINIMUM quality that should be relied upon for duty or self defense. I cringe when I hear that anyone is relying on a stock Kimber for anything more than a range toy.
With regards to LAPD....yes, LAPD SWAT bought a bunch of TLE II's. I challenge you to find one that is unmodified that is being carried by them. Yes, LAPD's SIS bought a bunch of Kimber 1911's. Probably about 95% of that unit is carrying Glock 21's and 22's. Kimber's marketing is not reality.
I own a Kimber Custom Classic (pre-Series II). I had some "issues" with the gun (i.e. it didn't work). I sent it off to a very competent pistolsmith who posts on this board. I told him I simply wanted it made reliable. He told told me he would only replace what he had to. The only factory parts left on the gun are the slide, barrel and frame. FBI clue folks.
To any LE folks out there that want to carry a 1911 at work or off duty. You NEED to be extremely familiar with the platform before you even ponder carrying one at work or for self defense. You better be able to tear it down to the last pin and springs and be able to build it back up without thinking and have a decent understanding of how the parts interact. You also must be able to do a 2,000 round challenge with your gun without any issues to make sure it is reliable and test it with lots of different shapes of bullets. If you can't do any of these things then look to a Glock, M&P or something similar.
If I had only $1300 to play with for a 1911 I would either decide on going to a different platform or would look for a used Wilson or Baer. I still would have them checked out and run 2000 rounds without cleaning through them before carrying them. A distant second would be to purchase a Colt Gunsite Edition (if you can find one) or a Colt Combat Elite and have them checked out by a competent 1911 smith (which there are very few of).
I have not handled and don't know enough about STI's products since they refuse to support law enforcement and faithful supporters of the 2nd Amendment out here in California.


Reply With Quote

Bookmarks