Sig 229 9mm DAK to Glock 19 Gen 3/Gen 4?

[1st watch]

I work for the largest PD in Illinois that until about 2 years ago, did not authorize Glocks, M&Ps, or XDs. I haven't been unhappy with my Sig 229 9mm DAK, but I really enjoy shooting and firearms in general and am seriously considering buying a Glock 19 for duty. However, I am torn on the Gen 3 versus Gen 4 debate. For all the forum members, especially DocGKR and LAV, what would personally convince you to trust your life with a Glock 19 Gen 4?

[F-Trooper05]

You may find the current PT endurance test useful in your decision...

http://pistol-training.com

[Beat Trash]

Gen 3 Glock 19.

Some have had good luck with Gen4 guns. But some have not.

The Gen3 guns work...

[John_Wayne777]

Not to speak for either man, but I believe both would advise you to stick with the Gen3 as a duty gun. Even then, you should thoroughly test the Gen3 gun to make sure none of Glock's recent changes will impact that weapon.

Personally speaking...if your Sig P229 is running well and doing what you want it to do, and if you don't find it to be a major impediment to anything you're doing...sticking with it would be my advice.

[streck]

If this is a duty weapon, what problem are you trying to solve or prevent by changing?

[LRB45]

Not to speak for either man, but I believe both would advise you to stick with the Gen3 as a duty gun. Even then, you should thoroughly test the Gen3 gun to make sure none of Glock's recent changes will impact that weapon.

Personally speaking...if your Sig P229 is running well and doing what you want it to do, and if you don't find it to be a major impediment to anything you're doing...sticking with it would be my advice.

What are the changes are you talking about? Good/bad?

I know that I'm looking at the Gen 3 Glock 19 to purchase soon so would like to know of any shortcomings.

Thanks

[1st watch]

If this is a duty weapon, what problem are you trying to solve or prevent by changing?

Well, I can't say that I'm trying to solve a problem or prevent one. Rather, I simply enjoy shooting, appreciate many different types of firearms, and wanted to try a different platform. I have 10 years in law enforcement, and was issued a Glock 17 with my first PD. So, I do already have familiarity with Glocks. I liked how the M&P 9mm felt and shot, but wanted something closer in size to my P229. If I do make the change, I would need something that is flat-out reliable if/when the time comes and is concealable for off-duty carry.

[John_Wayne777]

What are the changes are you talking about? Good/bad?

I know that I'm looking at the Gen 3 Glock 19 to purchase soon so would like to know of any shortcomings.

Thanks

They changed the extractor fairly recently even on the 3rd gen guns and I've seen a couple of reports of those guns having some issues.

[VolGrad]

Stick with Gen3 and like JW stated .... one made prior to 2010 just for good measure.

I recently got rid of my Gen4 as it just never proved itself 100% for me. I am back to all Gen3 and have NO regrets.

[Bulldog7972]

Not to speak for either man, but I believe both would advise you to stick with the Gen3 as a duty gun. Even then, you should thoroughly test the Gen3 gun to make sure none of Glock's recent changes will impact that weapon.

Personally speaking...if your Sig P229 is running well and doing what you want it to do, and if you don't find it to be a major impediment to anything you're doing...sticking with it would be my advice.

I'll second that. I also work for the 2nd largest Police department in the nation and carry a 226DAK. For awhile I was sipping the Glock koolaid and was thinking about trading that 226 in for a G17 until I came to my senses and asked myself why. I have never had a malfunction with my Sig, it has served me well all these years especially when I have needed it, I have tons of mags for it along with all the duty gear. So why get rid of it and go to something else? Plus, once you take that transition course (if it ever becomes available) you cannot carry that Sig anymore. Will you become more proficient with a new Glock? Is there anthing that one can do with a Glock that cannot be done witha Sig? I doubt it. I would suggest that you would be better served by keeping the Sig and using the money you were going to spend on a new Glock for some training courses outside the department. I guarantee you that if you keep that Sig, get some REAL training outside the department you will be a far better shooter with that Sig than most of the guys are with their Glocks. Just my 2 cents. Take it for what it's worth.

BTW, are you in Area 1,2,3,4 or 5?