I'll reiterate what I think is really good advice given so far.
1. It depends on what you will use them for. You probably won't need a super stiff shank and sole if you are only using them for low weight and mileage - light hiking etc. Merrells seem to be very popular all around if they fit your needs.
2. Try every pair on you can (preferably at a knowledgeable retailer like REI).
Take some time, 10 or 15 min, and walk around the store in each boot. You will discover hot spots and get an idea of fit. If you can't take time in the store, wear them in your house for an extended period. You'll get an idea about the comfort and can return them as long as they aren't dirty. This will take time, but it's worth doing to save you money and blisters in the long run.
In the end, I bought a pair of Montrail Gore-tex boots after trying 4 or 5 different boots in the store. They offered wide widths and fit me and my needs the best. REI and LL Bean are good values.
Consider replacing the insoles immediately with Superfeet insoles and buy good quality socks like Smartwool or similar. You won't be sorry.
Good luck.
Bookmarks