Replacing collapsible stock with fixed stock.

In other words, it needs to be pinned.

Well that sucks. I was eyeing this as a solution for movement to ban areas.

While “it’s better to be safe than sorry” works for most, I have yet to be shown proof that this is a fact. I’ve never been able to find a definition of “Permanently attached”. Some people will say the stock needs to be “blind pinned” others will say to use epoxy and other shit. I would like to see where this whole “pinned from one side” stuff comes from, I think it’s people who think they know more than the next guy making up definitions for the BATFE and then it gets repeated and taken as fact. Remember a pin could relativley easily be drilled out too.

I live in the Buffalo area. I cannot wait to retire on a nice 50+ acre spread in east Texas somewhere. I haven’t brought everything up yet, but I want to get my weapons taken care of before I bring them up. I am very familair with the M4 platform and usually shoot it fully extended so I wasn’t too concerned with a fixed stock. I was too accustomed to the A2 feel. I keep it collapsed for transport and storage.

I hear you. I may just swap it out with a fixed one just to avoid any problems. I don’t anticipate any issues with pinning, but I can just swap them back when I move back.

Do whatever your comfortable with. I have rifles with “pinned” stocks and rifles with fixed length stocks. I pinned all of my stocks and I’m confident that they all meet the legal requirements. If you can’t adjust it without using tools or taking the shit apart “I’d say your fine”. I pinned an E-Mod by removing the battery tubes drilling through the RE and the stock. I then drove a pin,metal dowell, through everything and put the tubes back on. If that’s not good enough too bad. I don’t see a policeman or anyone else EVER having a reason to remove my battery tubes from my stock.

In researching the NY law, it states a “folding or telescoping stock”. Does the Rifle Modstock fold or telescope or is the cheek weld adjustable part?

Not sure. If you use a standard rifle RE you would be good though.

take a look at the sully stock from http://www.thedefensiveedge.com/category_s/51.htm

can you forgo any muzzle device at all? Just have the barrel without one? I remember they used to sell rifles like that during the AWB

As long as it’s not threaded. Even thread protectors need to be permanently attached.